What's Your P4P List For Noue-vember?

Something like this...
1. Oleksandr Usyk
2. Naoya Inoue
3. Dmitry Bivol
4. Saul Alvarez
5. Josh Taylor
6. Vasyl Lomachenko
7. Errol Spence Jr
8. Gennadiy Golovkin
9. Terence Crawford
10. Kazuto Ioka
11. Roman Gonzalez
12. Kenshiro Teraji
13. Tyson Fury
14. Artur Beterbiev
15. Juan Francisco Estrada
16. Jermell Charlo
17. Anthony Joshua
18. Devin Haney
19. Emanuel Navarrete
20. Shakur Stevenson

 

I come across a lot of people who have Spence ranked #1 and even many outlets like ESPN, The Ring and CBS have him ridiculously high in their rankings

ESPN have him #3 behind Terry and Inoue
The Ring have him #4 behind Usyk, Inoue and Terry
CBC have him at #2 behind Inoue

So that's two outlets who have him above Usyk which is absolutely insane

This content is protected

Errol is a one-weight three-belt unified champion

All bar two of his fights were in the US and one of the ones that wasn't was in Canada and he was fighting a South African. So he's only fought in his opponent's country/backyard once and, as is often the case when a top American travels, when he did that they wanted to award him a medal of honor for it

He's beaten 7 world champions in 28 fights

But he's only fought two career 147 pounder world champions since winning his first world title and one of them was his title winning effort against Brook and he struggled badly against both. Everyone else world class he's fought was a a career 140 pounder or a blown up 135 Mikey

Brook
Porter

All career 140 pounders or a blown up 135 Mikey

Danny
Mikey
Ugas
Peterson
Algieri who was the first world champion he fought

And they're all either featherfists (Algieri and Peterson) or average punchers, especially at that weight.

Mikey is a big puncher but his KO% above 135 = 0%

Danny can crack but he's only stopped 4 of his 10 opponents at 147

Peterson was the WBA regular champ at 147, winning it against Avanesyan

Danny won the WBC title at 147 but that was PBC smoke & mirrors because he fought for the vacant belt against Robert Guerrero who was 2-2 in his last 4 fights, both losses wide (Floyd & Thurman) and even worse he could very easily have been 1-3 because a lot of fans thought he lost his previous fight against Aaron Martinez who dropped him

So Guerrero earned his world title shot vs Danny for going 2-2 in his previous 4, going like a death against a D level in his previous fight in a fight many had him losing. His other win (his only non highly controversial one) during that four fight sequence was against Yoshihiro Kamegai

Now compare that to Usyk

Usyk is a two-weight champion

Undisputed at CW
Three-belt unified at HW

He won, unified, and defended all his world titles at CW in his opponent's backyards sans his first defence which was on neutral soil

He won all his belts at HW in his opponent's backyard
Defended them on neutral soil

He's beaten 6 world champions in 20 fights

All the world champions he's fought bar one were career CWs or HWs in AJ's case not career LHWs or blown up SMWs who'd come up and none of them were regular champs. The only one who'd come up from LHW was Bellew but he was the poster boy for weight bullying and was very much a natural CW who looked like a vampire on crack on the scales at LHW, and he won his only world title at CW knocking out one of the best CWs of this generation who is the current WBC champ

And in complete contrast to Spence he's fought a ton of punchers and they were all career CWs or career HWs ie. his size or way bigger

We've never seen Spence put in a dominant performance against a career 147 pounder world champion yet and he's only fought two of them. He looks great against all those career 140s and blown up 135 Mikey who've come up whom his size, strength, physicality, and power are huge assets for him but on the two occasions he fought career 147 pounders world champions he struggled badly and even though he's barely fought any punchers he's been hurt a bunch of times

We've not only seen Usyk dominate career CW world champions his size many times we've seen him do so against giant career HWs way way bigger and heavier than him. In fact, Usyk has not only dominated most of the world champions he's fought he's toyed with them in their backyards and he's never been hurt by any of the big/huge punchers he's fought

How is this even a question? There is zero argument for having him above Usyk other than him being American