Where do you guys rank Manny Pacquiao all time status

I have him also in the 15-25, closer to 20-25.

It really depends on mostly what his defeated opponents do after (Cotto, Margo, JMM, etc) and anything else he does from now on.

JMM stock is rising.
Cotto is a bit flat for now.
Margo's stock is falling.


But if he retires right now and all his pass opponents retire today I would not have a problem putting him in top 25.

Beat JMM, PBF and a top 140er and I might put him in the low teens.

 

Do the 28 people who voted 2-10 want to explain themselves?!?

He's somewhere 25-30.

 

Top 20 but closer to 20.

 

goat duh

 

you also need to call out those who voted overrated.

 

Top 20 right now for me. If he beat Mayweather or Martinez, then top 10.

 

Top 30

 

Above HIM, But Below THEM.

 

Outside my top 30 Euro list.

6 votes for GOAT.atsch:klitfanb:

 

Nowhere. I don't believe in the concept of "All-Time Greats"

 

I rank him as an All time Great. No such thing as the GOAT IMO. There is just All Time Great without a level higher than that. Every All Time Great has another all time great who would beat them stylistically. Nobody is the GOAT.

 

Can't really compare him to fighters from different era. Just not fair,who is to say he can't beat leonard or duran or hearns or hagler.