I find it difficult to understand how anyone rates him outside of the top 3, unless they rely heavily upon hypothetical H2H scenerios and under value old timers or over value the modern eras.... Personally I rate him #3, but depending upon differing times of evaluating he has a valid argument for 1-3....Right now I go Benny, Roberto & Joe, but he deserves to be considered as top 3 and that seems the general consensus.
My Lightweight rankings 1. Benny Leonard 2. Pernell Whitaker 3. Joe Gans. Pound for Pound? I'm not sure exataly. Top 25 for sure. I'm only commited to a top 6 in terms of pound for pound.
I think both Leonard and Roberto are greater than him. I think he's as great as Whittaker, Armstrong and Williams all of whom I'd pick to beat him.
So Boxrec is the tool you use to describe activity levels in different eras, but the fact that it doesn't describe activity levels in different eras doesn't matter? I am talking about the highest levels of competition. Right now I'm looking into Tommy West, one of the most important contenders of his era, and his record is woefully inaccurate. I'm not talking about the Charlie Zelenoffs of that world, I'm talking about the Carl Froches.
Everybody is inclined to tip their hat to history, any man may acquiesce that a fighter was great for their time, but the beauty in Gan’s is that he is still combating that primitive prejudice. When newcomers see him smoothly dispose of Kid Herman, they may still be opposed to the economic, slow-burning tango of the 1900’s, but they will readily concede that this guy had something. Gan’s beautifully conveys through those flickering images that men in his era not only had a firm grasp of the finer details but that he himself was a truly exceptional and timeless talent. Timing, adaptation, grit – all the constituents that fashion our most extolled warriors he displayed like Morales does mileage. He has a good argument to be placed at the top of a heavily crowded lightweight division. And it’s hardly a far-fetched notion that he could’ve stopped Benny Leonard or bemused Roberto Duran. However, when it comes to resume, Leonard may just have the most impressive one ever recorded at a single weight.
The REAL Kid McCoy, if you asked him. :good But yes, I love that tricky, problematic man. I was actually asking McGrain, who his avatar was: Tommy West, who McCoy ironically knocked out in 1896.