Where do you rank Pacquiao on the ATG list after his Margarito fight?

My opinion: 31-35
Slightly behind Mayweather.
Clearly ahead of RJJ and Hopkins.
Margarito fight does close to nothing for me in terms of judging legacy.

 

:rofl

 

I stopped reading right there. Credibility out the window.

 

atsch

 

Not too many are better.

 

slightly behind your boy??
thats smart.

 

fixed. :good

 

as expected. atschatsch

 

top 10 for sure, but really, as i ve said- every fighter has fought the best of their era- of the greats, and floyd and manny- both have not.

its the one fight that will define exactly where they both sit. what if floyd, what if, he dominates manny. what if manny dominates floyd, and ko s him. what if they draw. the result of the fight- and how it is fought - could swing either mans greatness alot. i think manny gets more credit out of a win because he s smaller- than floyd does- thats just how the boxing world is. if floyd beats manny , he s top 20 - by most people i think, if manny beats floyd, he s top 5. thats not what i think- but what i think the boxing world will do with the result.

i think manny is top 10 already- but depending on how he does against floyd- it could swing 5 places up or down. what he s down, and more importantly, how he s done it- is incredible, and can never be underestimated.

 

top 5

 

Barrera x2, Morales x2, Larios, Marquez, Diaz, De La Hoya, Hatton, Cotto, Clottey, Margarito

Top 10

Add Mayweather to that...Top 5

 

A sensible post at last!