where do you rank peter after last night?

I say Top 10 only because it's a weak division

 

1. Klitschko
2. Chagaev
3. Maskaev
4. Ibragimov
5. Peter
6. Valuev
7. McCline

I think that's being fair and honest. I think the top 2 beat him fairly easily, the 3rd & 4th are more like 50-50 and could go either way.

 

I thought Mccline won:huh Peter was damn lucky to make it out of that 3rd round, Wlad Klits would beat him again, Valuev would give him all he could handle, and if older Klits comes back he would expose Peter too if his body, health hold up? i say Peter is in the top 5..

 

probably 3rd or 4th

klitschko
chagaev
peter

 

Kltischko and Chagaev are clear 1 and 2. Very hard to separate the next tier with Maskaev, Ibragimov, Peter and a few others

 

I think Virchis or Povetkin would have beaten Peter that night, but a ranking of #5 sounds about right.

 

Definitely below Wlad, Chagaev and Ibragimov.

Maybe below Maskaev.

He still won the fight so he shouldn't decrease so much his ranking.

I hope Wlad faces Chagaev or Ibragimov-Holyfield winner in Febraury.

 

I agree with this ranking.

No WAY is Peter above Oleg, Chagaev, or even Ibragimov.

But, PEter did win, and you gotta at least keep him in the top 5, but barely.

But then again, I am not sure I'd put Peter, even with the McCline win, above Valuev. Valuev is probably equal with Peter, as far as I'm concerned.

 

5th

 

His placement hasn't changed for me. I already had established champs in front, with Ibragimov being next to Maskaev as most takeable.

Once Sam beats Maskaev he will pass Maskaev and Ibragimov.

Don't forget fools, he WON the fight.

 

1. Klitschko
2. Chagaev
3. Maskaev
4. Ibragimov
5. Peter
6. Valuev
7. Brock
8. Liakhovich
9. Byrd
10. Thompson

Just missing: Virchis, Ruiz, Povetkin, Chambers, Rahman