Where Does Mayweather Rank on your ATG List?

That was when I also thought wladimir Klitschko was a fraud. My opinions change over time and I am man enough to admit when I'm wrong. When great fighters do great things I have to recognize it.

 

Then who is your top 10 pound for pound into 2015

 

I think he is beatable at 147 ,and by quite a few, but he certainly schooled Manny.

 

Timothy Bradley was p4p rated as one of the best in the world and Algieri had just come off a war with Ruslan Provodnokov. Would you really hold a loss to Marquez against him - a career long rival who still rates at #4? Let's face it.. Pac was a huge win.. There were many who picked him to beat Floyd even today... Of course he lost and the first thing that comes out of anyone's mouth is " pac was washed up" or " pac was hurt." Same thing happened when Floyd fought Alvarez.. People thought he'd knock Floyd into next year, and the next thing you know those same people were babbling " Canelo was too green, and fought a stupid fight." It never ends...

 

Floyd vs Oscar at 135-140 prime for prime. Great fight Floyd Wins Unan decision

When Floyd fought Oscar he went all the way up to 154 to meet him.

 

Please name them.

I think Floyd beats nearly everyone in history at 140lb. His best weight in my opinion.

 

For the record I see Floyd winning a unanimous decision over Gavilán.

Napoles? Jeez I don't know. I rate napoles really high top 20 fighter of all time top three welterweight of all time. This is a dream fight right here...

Napooles vs Mayweather I would make at 140. Two of the very best of all times

 

Well in 2007 I was only 20 years old. I was still a kid. I've Grown wiser since then

 

I also think Mayweather's resume is a lot better than napoles.

 

Uh ... yeah, I'd consider get sparked out cold at almost age 34 a something of a major setback.

I think most people were even saying "career ending" at the time.

There's some sort of special logic that gets applied here, so that Pacquiao is built up again for the MEGAFIGHT.

Not me.

I expected him to lose. Mayweather was a clear favourite
I was asking the same questions before the fight.
I've been saying for 2 or 3 years at least that the fight has lost its real significance.
Everyone knows this fight was 5 or 6 years too late.

Where's all this new tide of denial come from ?
I'm not understanding this logic.

Are you telling me Alvarez was the favourite against Mayweather ?

 

At 140lb these men right here have to be the best H2H

Sugar ray Robinson

Floyd Mayweather

Pernell Whitaker

Jose napoles

Sam Langford

Roberto Duran

Julio Cesar Chavez

Wilfredo Benitez

Oscar De La Hoya

Manny Pacquaio