Where does Mosley rank in your top 10 P4P list now?

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Izzy Vazquez
5. Bernard Hopkins
6. Miguel Cotto (That loss to Margarito means less now. Tony tried to load em against Mosely and got caught, you know he did the same thing with Cotto. Once a cheater always a cheater, he also outboxed Mosley when they fought)
7. Sugar Shane Mosley
8. Rafael Marquez
9. Ivan Calderon
10. Chad Dawson

 

Its a no brainer Mosley has more wins than JMM p4p wise outside his fights with Manny which he lost 1 and drew another all he has is Casa..Mosley over JMM !

 

Marquez's win over Barrera is more impressive than Mosley's win over Margarito. Many people thought he beat Pacquiao the 2nd time. He got robbed against Chris John, beat Juarez, and like you said Casamayor.

Marquez is also fighting prime fighters. Vargas and Mayorga were washed up and Mosley looked bad against Mayorga up until the KO. Lets be honest JMM should only have 1 loss over the last 10-12 years and that is the first Pacquiao fight.

 

6 or 7

 

You just lost serious cred saying MAB was robbed. Marquez won 7-8 rounds of that fight. MAB was an ATG too. Margarito is a limited cheat who has 1 great win in his carrer and that win is beginning to look tainted.

Casamayor has 2 wins over Corrales, should have gotten the nod against Castillo, and was back and forth against a prime Frietas. He is a much better figher than Margarito and Collazo ever were. Joel was definately a world class fighter.

JMM has been much more impressive over the last 5 years than Mosley. He has struggled against only one fighter in that time period who happens to be the best fighter in the world right now and he has been THE champion at 126, 130 and 135 in that period.

Mosley has looked less than stellar against the likes of Mayorga, a faded Vargas was giving him serious trouble in the first fight and he was beaten by Cotto.

Don't get my wrong Shane has put on some tremedous perfomances against Collazo, Margarito, and he was perfect against albeit a shot Vargas the 2nd time. Marquez has been far more consistent though. JMM is without a doubt one of the 4 best in the world at this time.