Where does Trinidad rank ATG at Welterweight?

Top 20-25

 

some one ranked him top 5??.....lol

 

I voted top 10 but meant to vote top 15.

 

That would be an interesting fight. I think Benitez's defense, slickness, and underrated hand speed would see him to a decision over Trinidad.

 

Since Tito is a natural Welter i put him top 5-10.

 

top 5

 

:rofl atsch

 

I have him top 10 based on actual accomplishments if I feel I am being objective. H2H he would be lower.

 

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Sugar Ray Leonard
3. Emile Griffith
4. Jose Nápoles
5. Henry Armstrong
6. Kid Gavilan
7. Mickey Walker
8. Barbados Joe Walcott
9. Pernell Whitaker
10. Thomas Hearns
11. Oscar de la Hoya
12. Carmen Basilio
13. Jimmy McLarnin
14. Tito Trinidad
15. Donald Curry

 

If you were to alter that list to reflect only H2H, how would it look? Best 2 out of 3....

 

Only head to head?

Trinidad would probably be #6-10.

 

too bad Curry could have been top of that list

 

Sugar Ray Robinson
Henry Armstrong
Jose Napoles
Kid Gavilan
Sugar Ray Leonard
Barney Ross
Emile Griffith
Luis Rodriguez
Thomas Hearns
Carmen Basilio

Trinidad around the 20 mark.

 

Had a shorter campaign at 147, but imo he beat better competition.

I also thought (and most people thought) that Oscar beat Tito.

What was your scorecard for Tito-Oscar?