Where will Usyk rank in a P4P ATG ranking if he beats Fury?

If he does so and retires undefeated, top 5 for me.

i kind of think that Robinson and Armstrong kind of have the permanent lock, but #3 not at all out of the question.

 

Voted #1 but thought you meant p4p rankings. I'm not sure atg, I don't think he surpasses PAC or Mayweather with a Fury win.

 

Would've loved to see Usyk fight Holyfield at CW.

 

Do people use this criteria when ranking boxers? If you were to rank a boxers amateur record as well as their pro record, surely people like Loma and Rigondeaux would be ranked pretty highly in an all time list. Just on their amateur record alone.

 

Top 2 Cruiserweight - Tie between him and Holyfield.

Top 15 Heavyweight.

LOL at people voting top 5.

 

No Lol. Very few have unified two divisions, one of them the unlimited heavyweight division, and retired undefeated....vanishingly few in the four-belt era. In fact, none at all.

You can disagree, but no Lol to it. It is a legit intellectual position.

 

Wouldn't crack top 30

 

Actually just realised this is P4P atg not HW.

But still though you have to look at calibre of opponent. Is AJ and past it Fury really enough to warrant p4p ATG top 5?

 

Yes. They are two of the best super-heavies to ever do it, and he is overcoming massive weight differences to do it.

 

All right, back to reality time. Usyk was 16-0 as a cruiser with some nice wins. He's All of 4-0 at heavyweight with wins over
Chazz Witherspoon 7 , ugh!
Chisora UD close
Joshua 2 UD'S and those wins aren't looking all that great now.
20-0 with 13 knockouts lands him in the top 30 of all time?
Not even close

 

He wouldn't be top 5 people come on..... Ezzard Charles ? Muhammad Ali ? Willie Pep ? Henry Armstrong ? Harry Greb ? Roberto Duran ? Sam Langford ?

I wouldn't even put Usyk above the likes of RJJ, Pacquiao, Mayweather, Whitaker, who beat alot more quality opposition.

 

Behind definitely I think Usyk has a slightly better Cruiserweight resume, but at Heavyweight it's no contest.

Holyfield has wins over Holmes, Foreman, Bowe, Tyson x2, Moorer, Mercer, Dokes.

 

Not top 25 - add that option