Where would you guys rank Mayweather if....

Top 10

 

Top 15 very easily . . . If he beats all those guys on top of his resume as it stands now, well its just bull****!

 

I think he only comes back for Pacman.

I cant see him fighitng Cotto now, only other guys would possibly be Paul Williams if he keps looking impressive, and Margarito maybe.

 

Actually Top 6 when u think about it:

Undefeated
World Championships in 5 weight classes.

Wins over:

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo
Arturo Gatti
Zab Judah
Carlos Baldomir
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton
Manny Pacquiao
Juan Manuel Marquez
Miguel Cotto
Antonio Margarito
Paul Williams

Man thats a hell of a resume!

But it wont happen.... He either wont face all of those 5 u mentioned or somewhere along the way he will take an L

 

Top 25-30

 

He is already the greatest of all time. so number 1:good

 

top 30.

 

I disagree . . . In my opinion numbers dont mean **** . . . How many fighters have undefeated flashy records but are just built up feasting on **** competition.... Not saying thats what those two did but as i said, you have to look at who the boxer fought and beat, because numbers can look impressive but be deceiving.

I dont think you should look at a fighters number of fights or wins and make a judgment based on that.

 

:rofl :rofl

 

maybe top 20

 

def top 5!

 

anybody to have wins over those names in their prime on his resume ALONE deserves to be in top 20-30.

 

I would place him high but imo he is lucky to get in the top 100 ATM and I also think he gets beat off a prime De La Hoya. Mayweather nearly lost (and did imo I don't see how anyone can say he won the first fight)at light weight and only proved himself as a great fighter up to light welter and as a very good welter where as De La Hoya proved to be great all the way up to welter and very good at light middle.

When Mayweather beats a fighter who is great and in his prime in a division in which he is at his P4P best then he becomes a great fighter but untill then he is not.

Even his wins over fighters like Hatton and Corraless are impressive but neither fighter was great and neither fighter put anywhere near one of their best P4P performances in.

 

:rofl

The last one caught me totally off-guard.