Where would you rank Floyd Mayweather on the greatest boxers in history?

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by iloverachel2, May 11, 2022.

  1. 6.5winmag

    6.5winmag Member Full Member

    257
    140
    May 1, 2020
  2. acie2g

    acie2g Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,256
    935
    Jul 21, 2010
    idk you got Genero who is top 10-15 at 130 you got Diego who was a top 5 SFW/LW in his era
    You got Castillo who is the best Lightweight since Chavez
    You got Manny who went on to become Lineal welter champion after losing to Floyd
    You got Baldomir and Judah who were the last TRUE undisputed champions at 147 you got Marquez who is an ATG and Floyd’s biggest rivals biggest rival
    Maidana a 2-weight champ who a very solid argument can be made that his only real defeat was vs Alexander in his first fight at a new weight with a new trainer.
    At 154 you got Oscar who was top 2 champ and an ATG 6-division champ, Cotto whose a HOFer only Puerto rican to win titles in 4 divisions went on to become LINEAL middleweight champ after losing and Canelo who beat an unbeaten Trout directly before and beat a damn near unbeaten Lara in the fight directly after and went on to win titles at 160,68,&75 since he lost to Floyd. Haters just hate because of personality and fight persona but as a FIGHTER Floyd is undoubtedly one of the best fighters ever.
    There is literally a round table on Mike Tyson podcast with Mosley sugar Ray and tommy hearns and they asked how do you beat Floyd and everyone of them said that they didn’t know what strategy you can use to actually beat him that’s high praise.
    Let that bias go!
     
    ellerbe and AdamT like this.
  3. acie2g

    acie2g Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,256
    935
    Jul 21, 2010
    Marciano ain’t GREAT though very good but not GREAT although as a heavyweight where anything can happen his record is impressive but unbeaten don’t mean nothing if you don’t fight nobody
     
    AdamT and Boon like this.
  4. Levook

    Levook Member Full Member

    138
    113
    Aug 26, 2020
    I see. If you don't think Marciano was an atg, then we're on different wave lengths I guess. Oh well, have fun!
     
  5. Hanz Cholo

    Hanz Cholo Boxing Addict banned Full Member

    4,715
    2,945
    Jul 11, 2012
  6. acie2g

    acie2g Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,256
    935
    Jul 21, 2010
    well I think it comes down to perceptive and how you take things as I said being a heavyweight with that record where anything can happen is remarkable to say the least so I’m not trying to discredit Rocky just that it’s LEVELS.
    Take Andre Ward for example he’s a ATG super middleweight but would I rank him with the GREATS of the GREATS
     
  7. Ph33rknot

    Ph33rknot “El Gran Campeón Mexicano” Full Member

    12,224
    8,159
    Mar 5, 2012
    May and Manny are 10-15
     
    AdamT likes this.
  8. Loudon

    Loudon Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    37,048
    6,385
    Mar 7, 2012
    There’s no bias. It’s just that if you’re wanting to place him top 10-15 of all time, across all divisions, throughout the entire history of the sport, then you have to get the microscope out and put him under serious scrutiny.

    His stats are very impressive. But again, they’re not actually as impressive as what you believe them to be upon closer inspection.

    For me, he could only be placed that highly on H2H ability.

    Some points to consider regarding your stats:

    Manny was faded and injured. He had shoulder surgery the following week. Floyd also took PEDS. No sane person really believes that he was severely dehydrated to the point of needing an IV of such magnitude, that it was classed as being a medical emergency. No one believes that, or that they just forgot to disclose it to the NSAC. It was obviously used as a masking agent, considering that Floyd never had weight issues, he was only 3.5 pounds at the 30 day weigh-in, and if it was legit, he’d have taken oral fluids instead.

    Baldomir was undisputed because the division was weak. In a stronger era, a guy like Baldomir would have just been a run-of-the-mill contender.

    JMM was a LW who was deliberately cheated on the scales.

    Maidana was a B level guy, and Floyd wouldn’t let him wear his preferred gloves.

    His win over Oscar was probably his greatest win for me. Because Oscar had great skills, and it was one of the only times that Floyd was completely outsized, in height, reach and weight. But we can’t ignore that it was a very close fight for 9 rounds, and that Oscar was faded and had been inactive.

    Cotto was also faded, as he’d taken beatings to Manny and Marg. Yes, he won the lineal MW belt, but only because Martinez was finished with bad knees. Martinez got a gift against Martin Murray beforehand in Argentina.

    Canelo was young and naive, and he was forced to fight at a C-W. Canelo wasn’t the fighter he is today. He barely beat Lara and Trout. And the only top level fighter that Trout has ever beaten is Cotto, which tells you where Cotto was at at the time.

    Regarding Hearns, he was just being polite. The strategy would have been obvious:

    To have boxed him at range, with a plan B of fighting him aggressively if needed, which would have put Floyd into a defensive shell.

    Floyd would have had no road to victory against Hearns.

    It would have been the worst stylistic match up in history for Floyd.

    He didn’t have the size to have outboxed him, nor the firepower needed to have stopped him.

    Had Floyd have fought 50 times against the best in Tommy’s era, he’d never have had the same level of success as what he had in this era.

    His stats would look very different today.
     
    Last edited: May 14, 2022 at 12:59 AM
  9. Your Mum

    Your Mum Member Full Member

    278
    203
    Jan 21, 2022
    Needs to avenge his loss to Jake Paul first
     
  10. Ted Stickles

    Ted Stickles Boxing Addict Full Member

    5,975
    1,853
    Jun 24, 2007
    When you rank the greatest of all time you have to look at more then just there record.
    ….. you have to take into consideration there opponents, there dominance, there willingness to fight the best ,and there willingness to take chances to be great.

    Floyd was the best of his era, and he is without question an atg …

    BUT, when compared to the accomplishments, and number of fights he had compared to those of the past I’d place him top 15/20 all time.Which is an amazing accomplishment when you have guys like Robinson, Greb, Pep, Langford, Ali, Louis, Moore,Charles, Armstrong, Duran, Wilde,
    B. Leonard, Ross, and others I may have forgot. Floyd is one of the greatest fighters I’ve seen in my lifetime no doubt about it.
     
    Last edited: May 14, 2022 at 5:48 AM
    AdamT likes this.
  11. AdamT

    AdamT Active Member Full Member

    1,270
    1,651
    Sep 18, 2019
    Great Post and agree

    I also have manny top 15-20, due to longevity and taking more risks later on

    Floyd undoubtedly is the best of his era and his haters know this deep down

    I can't understand how anyone can see top 20 or even 30 as an insult?

    In no order

    Charles
    Louis
    Langford
    Johnson
    Ali
    Burley
    Pep
    Duran
    Hearns
    Hagler
    Monzon
    Dempsey
    Leonard
    Robinson
    Armstrong
    Moore
    Rjj
    Toney
    Pryor
    Chavez
    Greb
    Holmes
    Tunney
    Arguello
    Sweet pea
    Etc
    Etc

    Look how many names I missed just top of my head. If I read over it I would add plenty and that's over 20 names
     
    Mteslamiller, Ph33rknot and Chrono like this.
  12. Boxed Ears

    Boxed Ears this my daddy's account (RIP daddy) Full Member

    50,615
    3,350
    Jul 28, 2009
    Richard Pryor is arguably the GOAT but not as a boxer, ya'll.
     
    Ph33rknot likes this.
  13. Daft P

    Daft P Active Member Full Member

    1,380
    39
    Feb 27, 2005
    This is a great question. What exactly prevented at least some of those fights coming to fruition? 2008 Cotto would also have been a good fight.
    I say if out of the fights you listed he does 4-5 and wins all of them, he would have a clear case for top 10, maybe even top 5. He did not want that. I should add that he most likely would have won all those fights, the only one where I am a bit uncertain is 2011 Pacquiao, but even there I would have given him a 60% chance to prevail.
    As matters stand I think 15-20 is reasonable.
     
  14. PH|LLA

    PH|LLA Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    78,618
    1,902
    Feb 1, 2007
  15. Above Deck

    Above Deck Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,877
    166
    Nov 10, 2008
    Best of his era. But not sure where overall. Limited footage of fighters in the early 1900’s makes its pointless to even speculate. But on what I’ve seen, to the naked eye, he’d be up there with Benny Leonard