Where would you rank shogun in your P4P list now?

I picked 1 simply based on his last victory (a knockout against another arguably top 10 p4p fighter) was much more impressive than either Fedor, GSP, Silva's and Penn's last outings.

Roger's although a top 10 heavyweight isn't the toughest challenge in the division, unlike Machida who many considered the best in a stacked division. Shogun handled Machida a lot easier than Fedor beat Roger's in a gruelling bout.

GSP was unable to finish a clearly out classed mid level fighter in his last outing in Dan Hardy.

Silva'a refusal to fight and his antics may be a sign of domination to some, but in the end, like GSP, he failed to finish a clearly outclassed opponent.

Penn loses his title in a shaky but close performance to Edgar.

 

That is absolute insanity !!!!!!!! , Shogun just fought a guy for 6 rounds won 4 of them imo and scored a KO too , who nobody else in the division could land a meaningfull shot on , and he ranks below BJ ????? GTFOH !!!!!!

Man i love BJ but come on , the guy is not better than Shogun P4P , not in a life time , i have Shogun sitting 4th behind , Silva , GSP & Fedor ........

 

Go check out Shogun as a baby in pride blitzing his way through that division too , back then Shogun was considered P4P #1 , there is no in the future with Shogun he's been there and has been ranked #1 before , and nobody could argue with Shogun sitting at the top right now , i dont think Penn ranks with the top 5 P4P i really dont , i love the guy but he's not as good P4P as the Silva , GSP , Aldo , Fedor , Shoguns of the world ......

 

3.Anderson Silva is doing too much messing around.

 

I like this list.