Where's OSCAR DE LA HOJA on the ATG List (?)

Surely there are more than just those 2.

 

Chavez, Whitaker, and maybe Barrera, JMM, and Morales. Maybe Hopkins but I want to say no. Other than that no. Yes, I'm harsh but I feel I have to be because I'm tired of the words "ATG" and "great" being thrown around like the neighborhood *****.

 

I agree that it should be strict, atleast the mexican 3 gets a mention:thumbsup What about lennox lewis or roy jones?

 

Lewis, sure but I'm not confident in saying that

Jones, no not at all

 

Oscar started off so well and wiped out good guys like Ruelas and beat Chavez up and stopped the guys he had to. His only weakness was when he fought the elite level guys who were prime. He just did not dominate them like he dominated the other guys. Great fighter no doubt. top 50? probably not. I voted for him being 75-100 just because of his lack of wins against top guys. And 75-100 is still good. That is the whole history of boxing.

 

I was just going to ask if we're supposed to give him credit for fights he lost

 

:rofl:roflatsch

 

Beating Pacquiao at the time would have no effect on him, considering he beat hopkins, pbf and mosley. He wouldnt have to fight pbf and pac even.

 

59 on my list