Which among these Recently Active Boxers do you consider as ATGs?

I'm just overtired and cranky....Joe Calzaghe pisses me off. Ignore my rant atsch

 

well if you base your opinion on Lopez just based on his resume theres a lot of fighters that rank ahead of him on a list of ATG,but if you based it on skills he ranks high with the best.

 

You have to take into account H2H, and hypothetically what his resume would look like if he actually had some other great fighters in his division. It would look outstanding, theirs nothing the guy didn't have.

 

Calzaghe and Lopez...that is all...Winky is knocking on the door though..

 

he was great theres no doubt about that,its a shame he didnt move up earlier in his career to face Carbajal and Gonzalez.

 

Ricardo Lopez without a doubt. Like Joe he's undefeated but 50-0...but unlike Joe Ricardo has a resume with a lot of substance, fighting the best in his division during his prime and even post prime form.

 

its his skills that put Lopez high on lists cause is resume is nothing special even Calzaghe has a better resume than Ricardo.

 

of all those guys, only Ricardo Lopez.

 

Love your Avatar Socrates, where you get it??

 

Winky by far the best claim
But I also like Lopez
Calzaghe and zu are great they fought alot of old fighters to build there records HOF for sure though.

 

Dawg is that Megan Fox?

 

I only consider the all-time top 50 worthy of the title "atg", so imo none of them are ATGs. None of them are even close.

Roy Jones, Bernard Hopkins, Floyd Mayweather, Manny Pacquiao. These guys are the ATGs of this era.

Guys like Lopez, Calzaghe and Tszyu just do not have the resume. Not even close, as I said.

 

True, they are all ATG's, but Calzaghe is the King of ATG's. He even looked bored against other Atg's like Bhop and Roy Jones. And if anyone tries to say, "it was against an old Bhop or old ROy Jones." let me remind you , this is was an "old" Calzaghe that looked bored too.