Which Heavyweight Champion had the most text book boxing skill? Where does your choice lie? Wth Corbett? Tunney?Charles?Ali? Holmes? Or another? Lets have your pick.
Joe Louis, I would say, quite clearly. He doesn't do anything odd or lazily (usually). Perfect textbook punching, textbook footwork, chin down, his hands could be higher but that's about it. Hollyfield. Liston.
''Textbook'' is a loaded word as everybody boxes differently. Many champions have had a conventional style, but if you look its the most un conventional heavyweights who make it in to the top list, Ali, Frazier, Tyson, Lewis, Marciano, Dempsey etc are hardly 'conventional'...
Joe Louis under the guidence of Chapie Blackburn, if you were to try and copy the execution of a punch look at Joe, short, compact,presice, and his combo's and jab were the best as far as power combo's. Marciano as far as getting all his weight ,leg,back and arm muscles behind a punch,every shot was dense...Ali for speed, Lennox learned from Manny how to set down on a punch...Louis was the best
I dont mean to be rude but what text book? As a coach you go with the flow but there is no such thing as a text-book method ; the so called classical style( jab-back hand) suits mosts guys but crucifies some-to say there is only one way is nonsense.
My vote would go for the Bomber. Though I think Tunney was the purest boxer of any of the heavyweight champs.
Text book in the overall sense of the term or the puncher's sense of the term. If it is the puncher's sense of the term then I would say that Joe Louis is the obvious choice. But if it is in terms of overall skill and style then my picks would be: Gene Tunney Larry Holmes James Corbett Jersey Joe Walcott Ezzard Charles Evander Holyfield
Homes seemed to be a little unorthodox to me in terms of pure text book standards. Sure, he mastered all the basics, but he constantly measured his opponents with his left hand extended in their face. Nothing wrong with this, but it isn't very common among household named fighters. He also resorted to the uppercut, usually when in trouble rather than incorporating during other circumstances. I think Joe Louis in terms of mastering the pure fundamentals of punching, was a good pick. He was almost perfect in every punch that he threw. A real master of his craft.
I cant see the statement ,"there is only one way"anywhere in my post,everyone knows a lot of fighters have been extraordianarily effective ,without being conventional,so I think you are challenging a mirage.Unconventional boxers I might name would be Ali and RJJ,for eg,my choice for the greatest "classical boxer " of the Heavyweight Champions would be Tunney.