Which is the better win?

Mayweather beating Mosley.

 

Mayweather beating Mosley, of course. Shane is an ATG, whereas Clottey is merely a decent contender.

 

actually it was cotto but i still agree; mayweather beating mosley is superior to both

 

floyd

 

FM beating SSM because Shane has looked better than Cotto recently + beat the man that fkd Cotto up.

 

Shane is the man to beat..Cotto was not the man to beat...simple as that

 

You should have did a public poll.

 

You mean Clottey? If so, I'd have to go with Mayweather beating Mosley over Pacquiao beating Clottey, but not by much. Clottey is in his prime, Mosley isn't. Clottey is much bigger and stronger than Pacquiao. Mosley and Mayweather are about the same size. But like I said, I'd have to go with Mosley because he is a bigger name than Clottey.

 

I would say Mayweather beating Mosley. I scored Mosley vs. Cotto a draw. Not only that, but Mosley is considered the top WW and Cotto may have been damaged goods and was possibly a bit drained going into the Pacquiao fight.

 

Mayweather beating Mosley. All respect to Cotto but I think Shane is a better fighter with Nazeem then he was with his father back then he would not use strategy.