Which List Means Most To You, ATG or all-time P4P?

Bingo. But for the most part this conversation is restricted to the heavyweight division because there's no weight limit. Other classes solve this issue by having weight limits.

 

That must have been a tough call for you considering that Robinson defeated LaMotta 5 out of 6 times...

 

There is no difference between them. Take any weight division. Bantamweight.

The greatest bantamweight of all-time is the bantamweight of all-time pound-for-pound. It's the same guy.

And the heavyweights are automatically pound-for-pound because of the unlimited nature of the weight division.

 

Then put together you own ranking and rate them where you think they belong

NO, I would not. Hearns was not in his prime when he lost to Barkley. And he was not fighting at his prime weight either.

 

What about conditioning, heart, chin, power, athleticism? There are millions of guys the size of Lewis. Some of them couldn't grab their @ss with both hands. A crack on the chin from a flyweight would put some of them in a coma. Lewis was much more than his size.

 

It is the same in any division. Do I have to write it eight times?

The greatest flyweight of all-time is the flyweight of all-time pound-for-pound. It's the same guy.

The greatest bantamweight of all-time is the bantamweight of all-time pound-for-pound. It's the same guy.

The greatest featherweight of all-time is the featherweight of all-time pound-for-pound. It's the same guy.

The greatest lightweight of all-time is the lightweight of all-time pound-for-pound. It's the same guy.

The greatest welterweight of all-time is the welterweight of all-time pound-for-pound. It's the same guy.

The greatest middleweight of all-time is the middleweight of all-time pound-for-pound. It's the same guy.

The greatest light heavyweight of all-time is the light heavyweight of all-time pound-for-pound. It's the same guy.

The greatest heavyweight of all-time is the heavyweight of all-time pound-for-pound. It's the same guy.

I'm not going to do it again for all the junior/super weight divisions.

 

You don't understand that the heavyweight division is unlimited? Lewis fought heavyweights - some weighed more, some weighed less. It seems to me that when you are talking about size you mean height. We don't have height divisions.

It's not Lewis' fault that Bowe ducked him. A fighter can only fight those who have balls enough to sign the contract. The guys that he fought weren't as good as he was, which is probably why he won and they didn't.

 

Mine is Carlos Monzon. But it doesn't matter. You wanna try change the subject now rather than engage the point I am making.

You started this topic. So don't duck it.