Which List Means Most To You, ATG or all-time P4P?

I hate Asero. I don't know whether it's that his point is lost in translation or that he has no point at all.


I suspect the latter.

 

You're right, hate is a strong word.

I don't hate you, I just dislike your posts. Very strongly.

Look, best form isn't considered in an ALL-TIME P4P list....that in itself is an ATG list.

Current P4P top 10 (i.e The Ring) is done on form, yes, but ATG lists (which feature fighters from all weight divisions) is done on a body of work.

 

So if Klitschko was no.9 in the P4P rankings and Mosley was no.6, then Shane would beat Wlad? atsch

look up the definitions of P4P and get back to me.

 

P4P is nothing to do with the same weights.

What you mean is ATG list in certain weights.

Damn you're irritating. I'm sure if more people were A) Online or B) Bothered enough to look at this awful thread would share my sentiments.

I won't bother replying again, I'm finished with this conversation.

 

no, styles make fights.

 

Get a dictionary and look this up: in my opinion.

Quit stating all this stuff like it is fact. It isn't.

 

Once again, you do the same thing. You mean, IN YOUR OPINION jones would beat calzaghe... Don't state it like it's a fact. It isn't.

 

1) Have you even read any of my posts? Didn't I just say that IMO the greatest fighters from each of the eight traditional weight classes belong in my top ten p4p of all-time?

2) Where do you come up with this? There are many who consider Zarate or Ortiz or Olivares or Brown or McGovern as the best banty ever.

 

So p4p Sandy Saddler over Willie Pep ?
ATG Willie Pep over Sandy Saddler?

 

They are one and the same.

But then again, this is from the same guy that says Flash Elorde was better than all-time great Sandy Saddler.

Consider the source.