Which of these guys are HoFs if they retired right now.

Casamayor and Wright.

Rafa and Vitali are borderline, but Rafa might get in due to the great spectacle of the trilogy, and Vitali for lack of other quality heavyweights.

 

i said darchinyan is top 100 if he beats donaire and wins a belt at 122...that is 4 division champion, quite an accomplishment

 

It would all depend on who he beat to get the title. If he gets a vacant title for beating a guy with a record of 23-6, then that doesn't cut it.

 

IMO, w/o analyzing it too much.

 

yes, i agree...but he defends it thrice i think he can make a case even if he beat a guy with 23-6 record.

it all boils down to cotto, darchinyan or wladimir on who of them would be the next fighter to enter the top 100 and make a case of an ATG status..

mosley and marquez top 100 status is still not secured but if they retire now, he are in the top 100

 

I think Marquez has to be in the top 100, personally.

He dominated at 126lb, and is currently dominating at 135lb.

I always feel he beat Manny Pacquiao, the premier fighter in the world today.

A lock, for me.

 

even if he loses to valero and pacquiao losses to cotto?

 

Pacquiao's accomplishments cannot be undone. Everything else is just a bonus now, he will go down as a top 50 ranked fighter.

I don't envision Valero getting a fight with Marquez, who will do all of his work at 140lb+ now, in my opinion.

 

i hope so...anyway in phil, Gerry is sureshot for Fil. HOF...

 

the guys I highlighted get in the hall.....they did enough, and I took into context the era, the resume, titles,division, and hall of fame standards....this is not the hall of greatness, but hall of fame.....and the guys in bold get in IMO.....

 

There's a separate pinoy HOF?

 

I agree. I almost didn't include him, which is why he was at the end of my list of Locks. However, when you really take a look at his resume, the guy was primo at 140lbs, busted up and stopped Kostya, and only lost to the two pound for pound number ones of his generation. I feel you just gotta give it to the guy after all of that.