Which of these recent floyd, Manny wins is the best?

Pac Hatton isn't on the list but it's a damn good victory either way.

 

floyd was the bigger favorite over mosley than pacquiao is over cotto. floyd was about 5-1 favorite while pacquiao was only a 3-1 favorite. also in ESB, pac-cotto was almost a pick-em fight while floyd was a clear favorite to win in ESB. also after that, cotto did continued to win while mosley has only proven himself as a shot fighter.

 

shane was shot to **** and looked like complete garbage. I don't care where he was ranked. he hadnt fought in a year and a half. That win meant almost nothing. That was barely a shadow of Shane Mosley in there. Pacquiao fought basically the same version, and that same guy drew with Sergio Mora 3-5 months after Mayweather.

 

Says the guy who said Mosley was arguably the best fighter Floyds faced even for his age. And it was a huge step up for Floyd. You even said you wouldn't be surprised to see an upset.

atsch

 

What a joke! The Hatton that Floyd fought was already exposed at WW by Callazo and as for the JMM signature win, another 'stacking the deck' move by Mayweather on Marquez by forcing him to move from 135lbs to 147lbs. That's 2 weight whole divisions past his optimal weight class and then not even bothering to make the agreed weight to gain an additional advantage.... Regarding the SSM fights, and this applies equally to both Floyd & Pac, neither faced a prime Shane, that fighter was long gone:deal

 

So stupid! First I voted for Pac v.s. Cotto but then I changed my mind to vote for Pac vs Margarito instead. How stupid I was.