Which of these three has the weakest resume: MOSLEY, MAYWEATHER, CALZAGHE?

b/c he ducked judah

 

Becoz Mosley was slapped across the ring by an average fighter twice and robbed Hoya in the 2nd fight?

 

average huhh...?

vernon was more than average & underrated imo.

and the dlh fight..... pleeeze.

 

How about Tyson?? he fought alot of noboidys when he was going up...including one or two at age 40

 

Co-sign. :thumbsup

 

Mayweather has the best.

Mosley's win over DLH in their first fight is better than anything on Calzaghe's resume IMO, but Mosley's resume gets thin after that. I don't see much of a difference in the resumes of Calzaghe and Mosley. I guess the DLH win is enough to give Mosley an edge, so I'll lean towards Calzaghe having the worst, but his and Mosley's are for the most part interchangeable IMO.

 

:deal :yep

:good

 

Mosleys is so clearly the weakest that it's not real.

 

thank god these voting results are correct

 

Jones wasn't a champion when Calzaghe fought him, it was Calzaghe defending his RING title.

 

Calzaghe has the worst resume

 

Mosely has probably fought the better fighters but I rank Mayweather & Calzaghe as better fighters than Mosely.

 

I think everyone, thread starter included, knew which way the votes were gonna go.



I voted 3 equally strong but Mosely has fought more A+ guys than FMJ & JC.
I didnt have time to rack my brain comparing FMJ & JCs records.


Botswana :smoke

 

When you go by who they fought it´s Mosley>PBF>Calzaghe. If you go by who they beat it´s PBF>Calzaghe>Mosley. Quite easy actually.