Which one is more convincing, PAC-Mosley or FLOYD-Mosley?

They both fought a shot, past it fighter, who cares? Neither were ever going to lose to him. Floyd beat him with his defensive style and pickpocket counters. Manny beat him with aggressive offense. How can you say one is more convincing than the other? It comes down to your style preference. The only difference in those fights, really, is that Shane was scared of Pacquiao's power and not Floyd's.

 

My ****! I am a fan of both but I can't believe how thick headed some people can be just to discredit Floyd. Floyd controlled the fight past the 2nd and throughout the fight he NEVER struggled with Mosley before and after he was hurt. THAT's a dominating performance. Pacquiao struggled to land solid combinations and showed inability to cut the ring off but no question he hurt Mosley more. We have to keep in mind that despite Mosley being inactive, he was WAY more confident in himself going into the Mayweather fight and on paper was coming into the ring after one of his best performances and quite possibly his last win. Mosley was coming off two crap performances going into the Pacquiao fight. Both Floyd and Pacquiao should be criticized for not fighting Shane the same year he beat Marg but Floyd beat a better Shane and easier. As far as Shane fighting different, Mayweather still knows how to CUT OFF A RING so he would never look as bad as Pacquiao did but on the otherhand he would nver hurt SHane as badly as Pacquiao did. I take a clinic over someone struggling to land&connect combinations anyday. C'mon, Floyd won much more effortlessly overall than Pacquiao no question. Floyd also did better with landing more than one shot at a time and never struggled with Shane's defense as with Floyd it was irrelevant.

 

This was pretty much how the fights went.

Pac also got a KD and wasn´t hurt anytime in the fight (Floyd wobbled in the 2nd round).

Floyd fought Shane a year before and Shane was coming off a big win against Margarito. When Pac fought Shane, he had lost to Floyd and has also had a disappointing fight with Bika.

Shane likes opponents who attack and keep coming at you - Pac is that kind of fighter. Floyd´s one of the best defensive boxers of all time. So you can´t compare the fights too simplistic.

Shane also fought these fights differently. From a spectators point of view Floyd fight was more entertaining - in the Pac fight all Shane basically did from the 3rd round was run and survive. Pac didn´t do anything spectacular in catching (cutting the ring etc) Shane.

If you compare these fights with Mosley in order to find out who would win the bout between Pac and Floyd, there´s not much to compare with. Shane fought differently and the type of the fight was different. Better comparison would be for example their fights against Marquez

 

Floyd couldnt land combinations either, whats your point? Shane was making Floyd miss a lot of his punches too, and he wasn't running like he was with Pacquiao.

Pacquiao outlanded Mayweather, had a better connect %, and he was hit less. As Floyd says "stats don't lie."

 

Stats are inaccurate as far as punches landed. Floyd had a much easier time connecting than Pacquiao did it's not even a debatable issue. He did it effortlessly but lets remember that both fought a Shot Shitty Shane.

 

Yup, Mosley couldn't hit Floyd, Floyd simply played hurt in the 2nd rd without taking any shot from Sugar, really!:rofl:rofl:rofl

 

You're right! Let's see how Marquez will perform against Pac at 144 lb this coming November!

 

they both beat a guy almost 40 years old instead of fighting each other.
who ****ing cares

 

Kostya Tzsu over Judah. Floyd ducked him!

 

its pretty clear that MOsely was afraid of Pac after round 3. He was never afraid of Floyd at all. Performance wise, PBF was able to showcase his talent. Pac showed he had more power.

 

knockdowns don't ****in' lie..:yep

 

Floyd beating Mosley was more impressive, and I live Manny better. But to be fair, Mosley did not have a big loss before fighting Floyd. Floyd beat him easily. Pacman fought Mosley who lost to Floyd easily a year before, and then had a draw with a very ordinary fighter in Mora.

 

Floyd-Mosley: 2nd round almost put Jr into the canvas. Fact.


Mosley was shot even when Floyd fought him. So a fight with Shane should not be a weighing scale on whos performance is better.