Definitely the Ring's. Boxrec uses numbers and P4P is a subjective thing so an objective measuring system like that doesn't work. Obviously I don't always agree with where the Ring puts certain fighters.
Not bad. I've seen far worse but there are still some things with it I personally find faulty. Donaire up ahead of Ward at #3. Mares should be below Viloria, both are 11 and 12 to me. Matthysse way too high, he just hasn't fought the comp to be up there.
the boxrec system has major flaws but it objective. the ring system is better since it is based on people's opinions but obviously it is tainted as the marketing men seem to have a degree of control.
Although officially considered defeats, Alexander and Judah are on his resume but I can see where you are coming from. I might have Matthysse too high but IMO he is the best junior welterweight in the world. I think Ward edges out Donaire in terms of opposition. Thanks for the feedback.
