Which ten active boxers have the best resumes - in what order - and who's top?

As I said, not too sure about the order, it's a hard thing to evaluate when you are considering wins, good performances, bad performances, and losses, versus name on the record and the condition that the name in question came to the fight in (ie age, weight, form issues).

I would place B-Hop above Winky, so I wouldn't have him any lower than 5 on this list even if I did revise it. I have heard Hop's resume dissed on here many a time (have even heard it compared unfavourably to Joe "Two Decent Wins in 11 Years" Calzaghe!), but when you look at the names on there that I've wrote, he has been in there with the best guys available, and won more often than not. I personally give him more credit than most for the Trinidad stoppage (Tito was 40-0(34) going into that fight, had stopped Vargas & Joppy in his last 2, and stands 5'11", has a 72" in reach and weighed in a pound and a half heavier than Hop! so he was a full-sized power-punching middleweight despite what anyone says), the Tarver victory (coming off 2 losses, jumping 2 weight divisions, and dominating the linear LHW champion at over 40 years old), the performance in the Calzaghe loss (IMO Hop controlled the fight, made Calzaghe so ineffective he was practically impotent, landed every significant punch in the fight, but just didn't have the energy/stamina/workrate to match his superior skills), and the stoppage of Glen Johnson (often forgotten, but no mean feat), so I stand by my choice of Hopkins.

Where would you have him? Do you agree with my other choices??

 

i thought this was about active fighters why barrera, holyfield, jones?

my list..

1. ODLH
2. Toney
3. Hopkins
4. Pac
5. Wright
6. Mosley
7. Casamayor
8. Cotto
9. Klitscho
10. Calzaghe

 

Pacman, DLH, Barerra, Cotto