Obviously Calzaghe's wins. For starters, Reid was never any good to begin with. Audley Harrison won a gold medal for **** sake and look how good he is! Plus they stuck Reid in there after something stupid like 12 pro fights. The win over Vargas was impressive, it was a great fight but Tito could have just as easily lost. Calzaghe has a shutout over Lacy and gave Kessler a boxing lesson unifying the titles. Self explantory.
Calzaghe beat titlist that were more solidified, but what made Titos victories so impressive is that he went after them right away after going UP in weight and fought them right after one another. He cleaned up that division real quick.