Whitaker on PBF: 'Maybe I'd let him carry my bags to the dressing room'

Mayweather UD, enough said.

 

This Whitaker we are talking about , its not like he lived a clean life the man is no saint himself..

 

if you disagree so much why don't you elaborate on how he couldn't beat Pernel :good

 

I am not the one who made the argument about Floyd beating Pernell. Let's wait until someone who agree with it post something.

 

Maybe PBF should pay Whitaker to clean the Toilets at his mansion. Floyd Jr. could pay him with little rocks of crack.

 

Floyd ****ing knocked Hatton out. Where you been?

 

:rofl:rofl

 

Judah and Whitaker are very little alike. Bad comparison.

 

i feel it's a toss up. really depends on what weight they fight at. and what stage they are in their careers at that time. a fight between 2 ATg usally ishard to pick unless the other atg is just at huge disadvatge. for example Hearns vs sweet pea. ... PBF and Pernel are actually quite about even in most department. but like some one else said we would never turly know.

 

How fighters stack up against a particular common foe tells us little as to how they would stack up against each other. Lose the smoke and mirrors in your analysis, imo. Secondly, Floyd won clearly.

 

****ed up but funny.

 

So you'll say here that Roger and Floyd are not unlike, but on the other hand are trying to suggest that Whitaker is just a better version of Judah's style, therefore he would win more than four rounds? Don't be a hypocrite.

 

Erm check the date on that post

Personally the more I think about it the more I think Floyd could win, whitaker was awesome and I think it would be a close fight, but if floyd fought smart then he could get a close decision.

 

Wasn't this thread started aaaaggggeeessss ago???

BTW, those picking Floyd are way off the mark. Sweet Pea is superior at everything.

I can't believe same people still think of Pea as a 'light hitter'. Even a quick scan at a rudimentary highlight selection will show just how brutal a finisher Pea wanted to be, especially at 130/135.

Floyd would not know what to do with Pea sticking a jab in his face all the time and moving out of the way of Floyd's offence.

Mayweather seems to have a good chin, but has barely been hit flush in his whole career.

Pea was hit late on in his career, and early on in his career; his chin always stood up. No way is Floyd even hurting Pea.

Pea fought trinidad and dlh in their PRIME. Neither could stop him. If the WW Floyd met up with Prime Tito and DLH, do you think he could've beaten them?


Don;t get me wrong, Floyd is very good, and a top 50 of all time great. But his style is to take a few rounds to figure his opponents out. Pea would already be way ahead by then, and, I'm worried to think what would happen is Pea took the fight to the inside. He isn't a fighter like Gatti or Hatton that Floyd could beat to the punch, and even with Floyd's mix, I say Pea beats him 117-110, something like that.

It wouldn't be a schooling by any means, Mayweather is far too talented for that. But Pea is better than Floyd at everything, common sense says he'd prevail.

 

Oh, true. Didn't even realize this was an old thread when I jumped in.