Whitaker or Mayweather - Most skilled?

He looked **** against hurtado. I agree with Chavez as his best fight though :good.

have you seen the first Ramirez? Daylight robbery.

 

Yup. That's why I was so happy when Whitaker gave him a Mississippi style ass whupping the second time around. :happy

 

Whitaker.

 

LOL NOT a single person that really knows this sport and knows the fighters wouldn't ever pretend pea is anywhere near Floyds skill level.
nevermind when a kid he beat the **** outta a undefeated Pro in pae. team floyd had to tell him to lay off a little which he did and still controlled every second

 

He always says that.

"Whitaker had no offense", "The problem is his resume".

 

1- Nelson
2- Haugen
3- Ramirez II
4- Chavez
5- McGirt II (Even though he got dropped. Buddy was class.)

 

I'm starting to hate this forum. Trying to stay strong though.

 

Against women only, but in Boxing Pea had a better offense by far.

 

Up to 2007 Mayweather was a +24 in punch connect percentage per compubox

Roy Jones Jr +20

Pernell Whitaker +16


But here's the difference, Mayweather at his peak averaged 45 punches per round, Whitaker averaged 62 punches per round. Blistering pace in comparison.

 

Compubox is garbage.

 

Sweet pea would make floyd look like a fool missing left & right with his 1-2s lol.You can't beat pernell by throwing pot shots even for a accurate fighter like floyd.You have to throw combos & hope you land a few here & there.

 

Yea.

 

Whitaker had a better jab better workrate and maybe arguably better defense. PBF better hand speed better counter-puncher more power chin and better ring IQ. I said better ring IQ because Whitaker clowned far too much in the ring and that brings him down a notch.

 

True that PBF is fare more disciplined than Pea was out of the ring always in the gym somewhat of a sick obsession for it. Also more focused inside as well. Pea clowned far too much and it rubs judges the wrong way. Perfect example against Oscar.