Who’s road to Undisputed was the Greatest?

Holyfield did it.

Lots of fighters have been undisputed in two divisions.

Usyk would be the first in the 4 belt era though.

 

Usyk and Golovkin.

 

indongo AND 0 title defense postol

 

lil g was never even lineal, much less undisputed

 

1. Usyk- Clearly

2. Canelo - Canelos wins against Smith and and BJS are very underrated.

3. Taylor - Prograis and Ramirez wins impressive.

4. Crawford - I am not Bud hater ( the opposite and I rate his as the best WW) but at the time he unified the divison it was weak and didn't have Taylor, Prograis and Ramirez.

 

Not sure why people are saying Usyk because it's clearly Taylor

Prograis > Breidis
Ramirez > Gassiev
Baranchyk > Glowacki

 

Based on what?
Briedis >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Porgrais
Gassiev >> Ramirez
Glowacki >> Baranchyk

Prograis = Gassiev
Prograis > Glowacki

 

Why is Clenelo on this list? Most of his fights at 168 are fixed

 

In order:

Taylor
Usyk
Canelo
Crawford

 

Usyk - Glowacki, Mchunu, Hunter, Huck, Briedis, Gassiev, Bellew

Taylor - Baranchyk, Prograis, Khongsong, Ramirez





Canelo - Smith, Yildirim, BJS, Plant

Crawford - Dulorme, Jean, Lundy, Postol, Molina, Diaz, Indongo

If anything this shows how weak Bud Crawfords JWW was. If Charlo become undisputed his run would be better than Bud’s and on par with Canelo..

 

I agree that its usyk then taylor. But i dont think its as clear cut as it seems. I think the prograis and ramirez wins are better in hindsight. Those were full on 50/50 fights, the briedis fight was nice but it didnt feel like a 50/50 match and the gassiev fight was a masterclass. I dont think Usyk has ever fought anyone in his level to say its 50/50, but i do understand the argument that usyk may be just that much better than taylor as well. Just to conclude, my argument for taylor is his road to undisputed was harder because he had to face more adversity against top level guys, but without prejudice to the fact that Usyk may just be that much better.

 

No. Usyk did it all on the road. Discussion finished

 

If Breidis was better than Prograis he wouldn't have needed a robbery to beat Noel Gevor.

A prime Jose Ramirez is also vastly superior to a one armed Gassiev in urgent need of shoulder surgery that would bench him for two and a half years.

And Glowacki ain't ****. Look how easily a crude rookie like Okoile dispatched him

 

Usyk. His run through the CW division was remarkable, beating opponents in their own backyards. Then in three fights at HW he captures 3 belts. All in 19 fights.