Who are th most overrated and most underrated fighters today?

I think Cintron is underrated
Arreola is underrated and hated on because he's fat
Margarito is overrated
Clottey is overrated
Joe Calzaghe is DEFINITELY overrated
Hatton is overrated...although recently my opinions are changing but i still feel he's overrated
Kirkland is underrated
Berto is underrated
Klitchko's are overrated...being dominate in a **** division
Taylor is underrated...the guy loses to Pavlik twice and he's forgotten :huh

There's more but i just cant think right now...

 

Overrated
Williams
Margarito
Hatton
Areola
Berto
Abraham
Gamboa
Wlad Klitchsko

Underated
Kessler
Haye
Cintron
Campbell
Vitali Klitchsko

 

Good picks.

I would put Dawson alongside Williams as the most overrated and Taylor alongside Kessler as underrated.

 

Taylor has ALWAYS been fkking underrated.

The guy beat Hopkins twice, Lacy, Corey Spinks, and held Winky to a draw.

How many other fighters in the world are even willing (much less capable) to do that??

Only has been beaten by one fighter, and there's a lot more embarrassing ways to lose than how Taylor did (like the way Pavlik did to Hopkins, for example).

The criticism of him is bullsh*t. People only ever look at how he "looks" in his fights and not who he's fighting or what he actually gets done.

 

I agree with you 100%. I love the professionalism that Taylor shows as well. That being said; I wouldn't use Lacy in my argument .

 

I'd say Bute is a bit underrated since the debacle in the last round against Andrade.

 

Overrated
Pavlick
Cotto
Kermit

Underrated
Clottey

 

Underated -

Miguel Cotto (just because he got stopped once doesn't mean he's still not one of the best fighters in the world)
Ricardo Torres
Nonito Donaire
Andre Berto
Chad Dawson
Sergio Martinez
Lucian Bute
Juan Diaz
David Haye
Amir Khan (yeah, thats right.....you cant write him off yet)
Alfredo Angulo
Victor Ortiz
The Peterson Brothers
James Kirkland
Timothy Bradley
Zab Judah ( dont count him out @ 140 yet)

Overrated

Joe Calzaghe (i like him, great fighter, ATG even but...british people hype him up too much)
Mikkel Kessler (one of my favorite fighters but, once again europeans make him out to be better then he is)
Bernard Hopkins (he's being overrated alot recently...same as with Calzaghe)
Paul Williams
Jermain Taylor (he cant beat Kessler, he cant beat Bute, he cant beat Calzaghe......he is not the future, he got dropped by bum ass Lacy for god sakes)
Ricky Hatton
Chris Arreola
Felix Sturm
Arthur Abraham
Kelly Pavlik

 

...

 

Antonio Margarito is only overrated by his nuthuggers

 

Havent you heard? Every fighter today is overrated in some way or another.