Who Are The Top Ten All Time P4P's?

You doubt that I understand the question?
I actually made the thread and posed the question.:huh


Laszlo Papp p4p top ten? Name 5 world class men he beat.?
He retired at 32 do you think his best days were still in front of him?
Where Charles ranks at heavyweight is not the criteria to rate him p4p I myself do not consider him a great heavyweight, but his resume is formidable'
Marshall
Burley
Christoforidis
Moore
Maxim
Baksi
Walcott
Layne
Louis
Lesnevich
Yarosz

What scalps has Papp got to compare with them?
I won't debate your amateur choices because everyone except you realised we were talking about professional boxers.
Fitzsimmons makes many lists because he held three undisputed world titles at three different weights.
You seemed to have missed the word PROVISIONAL that I purposely underlined in my list.:think

Making allowances for English not being


your first language, I think you are ludicrously absurd.

 

Since you didn't name 5 world class men that Papp beat I think we can both assume that is because he didn't .
Whereas as Charles easily did.The reason Charles won a title at heavyweight and not as the lower weights is because he was denied the opportunity to do so in those divisions.Charles was top ten rated in three weight classes.

Fitzsimmons won the light heavyweight title when he beat George Gardner the reigning champion in 1903 see link below.
He defended it aginst Philadelphia Jack O Brien who took the title off him in1905.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_lineal_boxing_world_champi

Harry Greb has probably the best resume of any boxer, that he is a p4p great is simply unarguable .

Lloyd Marshall beat:
Shorty Hogue
Teddy Yarosz
Nate Bolden
Curtis Sheppard
Anton Cristoforidis
Ezzard Charles
Ken Overlin
Freddie Mills
Jack Chase
Fitzie Fitzpatrick
Joey Maxim
Lou Brouilard
Johnny Romero
Bob Dunlap
Jake Lamotta
Holman Williams
Charley Burley.
His resume absolutely sh*ts all over Lazslo Papp's!


Luis Folledo never beat anyone of any note and every time he stepped up he was defeated.
If you look at my original post you can see that it has not been edited the word provisional was always there and underlined!
As I said ,you didn't understand the question.

 

He isn't for me. I said," others for consideration",there appears to be a lack of reading comprehension on this thread.:huh

 

You call Ken Overlin ,"a lower level opponent" yet have Laszlo Papp at number 5 in your all time p4p list?

Overlin had 165 fights and only lost 19 he was a world's champion and top ten ranked for 5 consecutive years Among others he beat are:
Al Hostak
Nate Bolden
Fred Apostoli
Steve Belloise
Ceferino Garcia
Ezzard Charles
Again his resume sh*ts all over Papp's.

You cant be this dumb! You have to be trolling!
Well done, you had me believing you were serious for a while:good

 

I couldn't care less what Papp did as amateur.I asked you to name 5 world class men he beat as a pro and you couldn't.Now I say name 3!
Papp was ranked as a middleweight in the top ten for just 3 years. Among the rated men he didn't fight are
Carter
Fullmer
Tiger
Benvenuti
Massinghi
Moyer
Fernandez
Torres
Giardello
Here are some of the ridiculous statements you've made.
1.Fitzsimons only won the vacant LHVYtitle
2.Fitzsimmons was a paper champ at LHVy
3.He never defended it
4.Ken Overlin was a lower level opponent.

There are plenty more, just about every thing you ever post is garbage of the first order.

You have the nerve to use a word like re****ed, best learn to spell it before you try using it again.

I still think you're trolling, nobody is that ignorant on their chosen subject!

 

You don't think Greb's resume is enough to give him a p4p ranking?

You cant see his fights, but you can see those of the men he beat ie.
Tunney
Walker
Loughran
Gibbons
etc

 

How about Greb beating rated opponents in three weight divisions? I don't rate either Norton or Young highly, especially Young who did not have it in him to go the extra mile.

Tommy Loughran isn't a big name? We disagree ,he comfortably makes my top ten at 175lbs.Having 3 heavyweight champions scalps helps.of course