Who are your P4P Top 5?

1. Calzaghe
2. Pacquiao
3. Cotto
4. Pavlik
5. Hatton

i know hatton will be a surprise to most but he has only lost to the then number 1 p4p (pbf). i think cotto will head this list in a years time once joe has retired and manny moves up to light-welter where he will be defeated.

 

1 JC
2 Pacman
3 JMM
4 Mijares
5 Izzy

 

1. Calzaghe
2. Pac
3. Cotto
4. Pavlik
5. JMM Marquez

 

Pac
Calzaghe
Cotto
JMM
Vasquez

 

1-pac
2-joe
3-cotto
4-jmm
5-izzy

 

1. Calzaghe
2. JMM
3. Pacman
4. Cotto
5. Vasquez

since P4P lists are personal preference, i thought JMM beat Pac in their last fight, so he goes above Manny.

 

Yeah but I thought Robin Reid beat Calzaghe about 100 years ago so he doesn't make the list at all.

I also think Castillo beat Mayweather twice so he is still in my top ten, even though he has slipped a bit; Why was Mayweather ever No. 1 by some people:huh

Why is everyone talking about Casamayor, Campbell, Pac, Juan Diaz, Katsidis etc. Isn't it obvious Santa Cruz is the man at LW, because he beat Casamayor with relative ease.

Great in the short term, but in the long game personal P-4-P lists do not work. I thought JMM won the last fight with Pac too, but I have to go with the result on the day or else, after a while, you will tie yourself in knots and your P4P list will look daft.

 

Calzaghe
Cotto
Pacquiao
Pavlik
Marquez

 

pac
calzaghe
cotto
jmm
vasquez

 

1) Manny Pacquiao
2) Joe Calzaghe
3) Miguel Cotto
4) Israel Vazquez
5) Kelly Pavlik

:bbb

 

Question:

Why do so many people have Kelly Pavlik so high?

I can't remember him being placed that far up people's list following the second fight with Taylor, and it can't be based on his victory over tomato can Lockett. Is it due to the hype surrounding a possible showdown with Joe C?

 

lol

 

1. Pacman
2.Vazquez
3.Pavlik
4.Cotto
5.Calzaghe-the slapper