who are your top five welterweights now?

Manny Pacquiao
Floyd Mayweather
Miguel Cotto
Shane Mosley
Andre Berto

 

Mosley, May, Pac, Berto, and.……?

 

im guessing he has that because mayweather is undefeated and mosley lost to cotto and looked p!ss poor against mayorga

 

This! :deal

 

same

 

Perfect list! 100% agree.....well...Shane could have manny's spot and Pac in Floyd's spot....But I really can't argue.

 

Agree, at least Mosley has a little case to be above pacquiao, but Floyd? Nah, no chance.

 

Alfonso Gomez.
Comming off Losses I couldn't Justify Rainking Cotto or Clottey at the #5 spot. Even if they both lost to Pacquiao who I have at #2. I don't think he is on the same leval as Breto, Mosley, Pacquiao and Mayweather but for now he is my pick for #5.

 

You mean ranking the boxer with the best record against the better compotion. And who has the better boxing skills as #1 makes me a ******ed?
I can live with that.

 

with cotto leaving

mosley
pacquiao
mayweather
clottey
berto

 

you can't be serious

 

lmfao..alfonso gomez...man please

u could put quintana or collazo at 5..even saul alvarez is above gomez....whats up wit yo picks? I know its your opinion but what puts gomez ahead of collazo or quintana?

 

It is dumb to place some much value on 'skills'.

What do you mean by PBF's better competition?
Mosley has the bet competition in WW in the last 2 years - Margo. That is Mosley's strongest case to be #1 in WW.

Pac faced the 2nd hard comp - Cotto. He also defeated 2 other WW with Clottey and ODLH. This combined three is his best argument.

What is PBFs? Hatton and JMM? Neither had any standing in WW before and after the fight.

I previously ranked PBF high too but him and recent competition at WW has done NOTHING in the division.

For me

Pac - his Cotto and Clottey win slightly eeks it out pass Mosley's Marg win.

Mosley - Most impressive win in the division in the last 2 years

Mayweather - mostly on his pre retirement standing. Can be argued lower to be honest

Cotto or Clottey - Clottey has faced hard comps and made it close (except for the Pac fight).

Berto is very close.

 

I think the winner of Mosley/Mayweather will be the man at WW.

 

no way anyone can become the man at WW without first going through Pac who just easily handled two top5 WW's back to back.