Who Beat Floyd More Clearly—Castillo Or Maidana???

What is this? Seriously. People actually think Maidana won that first fight? At the most he deserved a mildly controversial draw.

Here’s my opinion on the fight...Chino did well. There were times when Mayweather looked genuinely shook in there, especially in the 4th. But he adjusted...again. 8-4, 7-5 Mayweather.

 

Castillo has a legit claim to an actual win, I thought Floyd clearly but razor sharply beat Maidens and waiver back and forth between Castillo UD or draw.

 

Would you STFU? Nobody has even been in the argument of legitimately deserving a win over Mayweather since Lorenzo Aragón.

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/floyd-mayweather-jr-vs-lorenzo-aragón-july-31st-1996.456941/

 

The OP likely has an agenda given his profile pic, but your post is equally ridiculous. One could easily argue that Castillo or even Maidana beat him. They were close fights that probably should have been draws but had either been given a win, it certainly would not have been in the category of a robbery. People who talk about ODH beating him are delusional, but those 2 fights were legitimately close.

 

Legitimately close but the best case scenario for either was a draw. Under pro rules Aragon would have deserved the nod and even under what then was the amateur rule set in use he came within a whisker. So is my stance ridiculous or are you perhaps just under-informed on the subject?

 

Not Floyds biggest fan but I thought he won both

 

I had Castillo winning his first fight with Floyd and losing the rematch.

I had Floyd winning both Maidana fights.

 

Prime Pac would have tapped that ass. But Floyd waited till that cherry was so ripe it just fell off the tree.

 

Castillo clearly beat Floyd the first time, and anyone saying that there isnt even a legitimate argument Castillo won is just plain lying. There is also an argument Maidana deserved a draw in their first fight too.

 

Castillo maybe won the first fight, maidana lost both.

 

Clearly? With all due respect, when’s the last time you saw the fight not on a crappy YouTube rip? I have it on dvd, and neither guy clearly won, imo.

 

Void is retired and thank goodness for that.

But some people can't help themselves and keep bringing his name back !!

 

Maidana hurt him badly in the first fight, which he won but was screwed by Floyds vegas connections.