Who beat Maidana more decisively? Khan or Floyd?

You answered your own question.

Why doesnt Khan give Maidana a rematch? Maidana is more deserving than Khan was from Garcia.

Secondly, how would a 37 year old Khan do against the Maidana who fought Floyd?

 

Khan merely survived Maidana (with some help from Cortez).

Biggest difference was that Khan started strong against Marcos and gradually lost control until he went in full on survival mode, while maidana started strong against Floyd who figured him out later on and won most of the later rounds.

 

Khan almost got stopped by Maidana, and Chino is a better fighter now than he was then

 

atsch

He did not answer his own question at all....

 

I think Khan has the clearer win tbh. But Maywaether choose to make that fight intresting and it's quite funny that Maidana didn't get a point deducted for all the repeated elbows, rabbit punches, low blows and using the head when in close quarters.

 

khan easy so he can beat duckweater easy..........

Alexandra schooled maidana 12 duckweather lost
[url]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqjqcRf-tSA[/url]

 

[url]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqjqcRf-tSA[/url]

 

Prescott

 

khan

 

Agree with the poster who mentioned the way the fights played out too. But, as the OP mentions, Maidana has come a long way under Garcia - he's a much better fighter than the one who lost to Khan. I'd fancy Maidana in a rematch against Khan, but I'd guess that Floyd would widen the margin in a rematch against Maidana.

 

No question , Khan .

Khan won 9 rounds including a Knockdown .

He probably could have scored a TKO if that knockdown took place earlier in the round .

He also was able to Hurt Maidana which Floyd never came close to doing .

 

Khan performed better than Floyd and you know it .

Pretty much why you chose not to answer .

Khan outpoints this version of Chino as well .

 

Khan completely dominated and schooled him. But with the same ugly, sloppy and uncoordinated style Maidana was able to beat Mayweather... comes to think that May really ducked Khan too. Too fast, too reachy.