Who beat the Best Version of Margarito

Unequivocally Paul Williams.

 

he beat Cotto but he will never be the same after that fight!

 

Cotto for the first half of their fight.

 

I voted Pacquiao based on the fact the only other i could have voted for was SSM and i reckon Margo could not have been more motivated for any of his previous fights as he was for PAC as he had to be looking for some kind of redemption!

 

in order i would go

mosley
williams
santos
pacman

the margo that mosley beat was not only considered the best WW in the world, and was being talked about vs ATG's. but t was alswo a fight that had people fearing for mosleys health.

the margo that williams beat was on a good run and was a decent favourite vs a green opponent.

the margo that santos beat was capable of wnnng the fight was it not for the cuts. shame the fghts never really played out.

the margo that pac beat, well, lets just say he hasnt done anything of note for a while. the only positive for him being that his chin is still intact

 

Paul Williams clearly beat the better version of Margarito. Margarito before facing Williams was coming off a 11 fight winning streak at ww. And Margarito was consider the most fear fighter in the world. There was no distraction with handwraps.

 

which gives him more incentive to ko mosley to say i did it with out the plaster

give mosley his damn props yall he knocked out the welter weight champion which nobody else has done.

 

:deal
I've got to agree.

P williams won Absolutely beast Margarito who had Hands of Stonez.

 

Williams

 

I think you could find an arguement for any of them.
Williams - beat Margarito as a defending champ
Mosely - beat Margarito coming off his biggest win, scoring a KO
Pacquiao - beat Margarito at a weight more comfy for Margarito and with a 17lb disadvantage on fight night
Santos - beat Margarito when many didnt want to fight him

Due to the size disadvantage, I think Pacquiaos victory was most impressive. Williams struggled more than the others and looked least impressive in what I thought was a close fight

 

"I made a mistake. I wasn't trying to hide anything. I just screwed up, and I did it in front of Mosley's trainer and the commissioners. I was just under a lot of pressure because I knew we shouldn't have taken the fight," said Capetillo,

This content is protected

. - Javier Capetillo

Yeah, the best version of Margarito has to be the one that had to cut 30 pounds to make weight against Mosley then get caught trying to load gloves which put him in the best mental state before a fight in his entire career. :nut

 

Margs was with a real trainer, and looked better than ever in camp. He trained like he has never trained before against PAC.. Against Mosley he lost before the fight started, mentally if you're gone... you will lose. The Margs that fought WIlliams didn't barely throw a punch for the first 5 rounds... thats not that great of a version of Margarito.

 

SSM & Pac fought margocheato w/o plaster gloves
PW & Santos fought margocheato w/ plaster is a real possibility

 

Williams definitely.