Who beat the most HOFame (to be) fighters: May, Whitaker, Jones Jr. Pacman, B-Hop??

Thanks :good

 

Pacquaio- Wins; DLH, Mosley, Cotto, Barrera, Marquez, Morales, Hatton(borderline) Losses; Morales, Marquez, Floyd

Roy Jones- Wins: Mike McCallum, Bernard Hopkins, James Toney, Trinidad, Virgil Hill, Tarver Losses: Hopkins, Tarver.

Pernell Whitaker- Wins: Chavez Sr(should of been a win), Buddy McGirt, Azuma Nelson, Ramirez, Haugen(borderline). Losses: Trinidad, DLH

Floyd Mayweather- Wins: DLH, Pacquaio, Marquez, Cotto, Gatti, Hernandez, Hatton, Mosley.

 

Are you only going with guys who have already been voted in? Seems like there are some names missing.

 

Dlh

 

I'm not at a computer so I can't research this as fully as I'd like but at a glance, Calzaghe is missing from RJJ's losses.

I don't believe Genaro, Buddy or Haugen are in.

 

I think Hatton will get in eventually.

His achievements may be borderline in some peoples opinion, but we have to remember that other reasons sometimes come into play when voting boxers into the HOF. Excitement, fan base, impact, etc can nudge you in to the HOF if your achievements aren't enough.

 

I know De La Hoya fought: Chavez, Whitaker, Camacho(will be eligible this year), Trinidad, Mosley, Gatti, Hopkins, Mayweather, Pacquiao.

 

Shot Tito?!!! He was still in his prime(28 ) when he got smoked by Bhopatsch The problem was tito had no business fighting at 160lbs. He shouldve stayed at JrMW

 

Deep breath, I think you're confused... I wasn't talking about B Hop's resume, I was talking about RJJ's... Who fought a 35 year old Tito coming off a 3 year retirement at 170...

 

Ok so I'm a younger guy so I didn't grow up watching guys like Genaro Hernandez and Arturo Gatti. So what exactly did they do to get into the Hall of Fame?
For the people that did see their careers, do you guys feel like they deserve to be there? If so, why? I'm curious.

 

Gatti got in because he was entertaining and beloved, Genaro was a much better fighter IMO but he's not in.

 

Isn't there two hall of fames? I thought Genaro got into one of them. I have no idea, there is always two or more things in boxing (several world championships, several hall of fames, etc.), it's frustrating tbh.

So there is more than winning titles, title victories and resume to get into the hall of fame? Would popularity be one?

 

Yes there are 2. The WBHOF and IBHOF. I believe Genaro is in the WBHOF but not the IBHOF. I think in some cases popularity does come into it. Especially if the fighter was involved in FOTY, FOTD type fights. It's the reason I think Chico will eventually be inducted.