Who can Calzaghe fight and get credit for?!?

Like every win for any fighter there will be pros and cons pointed out but in the end he will get credit for any of the wins you posted.

He will get different levels of credit depending on the fighter though

if i had to rank the ones you posted i would say
1) Chad Dawson
2) BHop
3) Pavlik
4) Taylor
5) Bute
6) RJJ
7) Winky
8- Woods

I'm not saying which i think would be his toughest or easiest or what not just which i think he would get most credit for in the long run when looking back on his career.

if Taylor beats Pavlik then switch those 2, and if Pavlik beats Taylor easily then Pavlik goes up to number 1 or 2.

I mean Calzaghe did get credit for Lacy, and he did get credit (alot) for Kessler. To think otherwise would be foolish.

 

The thing is mate I can tell you're an intelligent geezer so why not rise above it & make them look small rather than lower yourself to their level?

 

Pavlik, Abraham, or any of the better cruizers and heavyweights

 

Dawson, Hopkins, Pavlik, Abraham.

 

Hmmm...and whose fault is it that JC remained fighting for the WBO 168 lb. title for many years in relative obscurity in Europe???

 

Chad Dawson only if he does well against Johnson.

 

Oh or how bout Rampage Jackson, Georges St Pierre, or Frank Shamrock :yep

 

The first 3 here.....

Woods (Abraham is the better fighter, but he hasn't beaten anyone and Woods has had a title for a bit, and fought Jones giving him some name recognition). Hell, if no one can come to terms, he can go take Erdei's lineal LHW title.

 

Calzaghe had his chance years ago when he was wasting his time fighting guys like Salem and Pudwill.

No matter what he does now, he will never crack the Top 50 ATG.

 

If he beats Hopkins and then Dawson, his stock goes up pretty high on my list. Assuming Dawson beats Johnson and Diaconu

 

Dawson *****