Who deserves a rematch vs Mayweather more? Cotto or Pac?

Cotto actually fought Floyd intelligently, and made Floyd have to stand there and fight him in the trenches.

That Floyd still beat him going away is a testament to Floyd's superior handspeed and defense. Pac looked completely lost.

Cotto.

 

Neither tbh. They both won about the same amount of rounds, so... I mean, idk. Manny since he brought in like 10x more money and is much higher ranked than Cotto on the ATG list? Since they both sucked against him about equally, I guess I just have to look at their resume's and Pacquiao wins that mark 10/10. Plus, he had a torn rotator cuff. So, yeah. I guess Pacquiao. Then again, I don't really care since Cotto loses this Oct/Nov.

 

:nono They did not both suck against him equally.

There are many different ways a fight can go and still be a 9-3 fight. Cotto gave him a lot of trouble and never let Floyd relax for a second. The same cannot be said for Manny.

 

Pac without any sort of testing woud be aweomse

 

The answer is easily Cotto and I'm happy the poll results reflect that.

 

Cotto fought Mayweather. Pacquiao boxed Mayweather. They both won around 4/5 rounds. You can give Pacquiao/Cotto three rounds, but that's just silly in my opinion. Let's also keep in mind Pacquiao had a torn rotator cuff in this entire mess. Once again, Cotto will lose this Oct/Nov so it doesn't even matter. He'll fall out of the Mayweather race anyways.

 

I gave Pac 3 rounds and Cotto 3/4. But Cotto made the fight very uncomfortable. Floyd was in cruise control against Manny.

 

Manny won 2 round

Cotto won 4

Cotto deserves that rematch and that's irrefutable.

 

Cotto actually put up a fght. Manny looked like a horse being led to water

 

Yeah that too. Cotto has fought much better. Comp than pac lately.

 

A horse being led to water? Why wouldn't a horse want to be led to water? Do you mean a horse being put out to pasture?

 

Pacquiao was getting exposed left right and center, that's the gist of it.

He won 2 rounds, and that's all he gets.

 

No I meant led to water. Manny was thirsty.

 

I don't really care tbh. It's such a redundant topic. Everyone pretty much has their minds set on what they think of the fight.