Who deserves a rematch vs Mayweather more? Cotto or Pac?

Nobody can say manny with a straight face, it's just basic observational skills you need to make the decision. We're not talking who is an ATG and who is a few notches below, we're talking who deserves a rematch congruent to each of their fights.

 

This person never saw Bradley/Provodnikov :deal

 

Lol what a fantastic fight. I'm pretty sure Bradley was unconscious for 80%. Flailing arms, eyes practically closed, mouth hanging open. Geez

 

Bradley is re****ed for going at Provo's space, herrerra & chris beat provo more convincingly than him, so much for being ranked #3 P4P, more like he got ranked only because he was american.

 

Deserve? Neither. They should've taken advantage of the opportunity they were given like maidana did.

 

Pacquiao won 2/3 rounds, Cotto won 4/5.

 

floyd deserves to redeem himself from pac and his father.lol

 

At 160, Cotto.

Anything under, Pac

 

Don't be ridiculous, Cotto doesn't fight at 160 :nod

 

Cotto. Because they will be not so many threads about the fight (for right or wrong reasons...mainly wrong) when Mayweather wins.

 

50/50 for me. Both definitely deserve it.

 

Neither one.

I don't know why people are so high on Cotto's performance against Mayweather. He was always behind on points, and never even came close to land enough to suggest an hypothetic stoppage.

In fact, he looked pretty raw and crude in there.

Nothing suggests he could do good in a rematch, and the best proof is that Cotto wants none of it.

 

Well I had Cotto winning 3 or 4 rounds, and I had Pacman winning exactly 3 rounds.

Based on their success in recent years, I'd have to side with Miguel. It also helps that he's currently the lineal champion at 160 lbs.

Both guys would get whitewashed in a rematch, but I'd favor Cotto over Pacman to get a second crack at FLoyd. Manny's performance was too disgraceful to warrant a rematch anytime soon.

 

I think people think it was competitive because Floyd was bleeding a little bit from the lip I think. People aren't used to seeing Floyd bleed at all, so that's what began this nonsensical idea that Cotto was competitive in that fight.

FLoyd really took it to him in that match. He wasn't just potshotting and moving around the ring incessantly. He stood his ground, fought Cotto and beat him pretty handily. It wasn't close at all.