who do u rate higher, floyd or shane?

You should have ticked the box that says public poll, that means we can click on the vote numbers & see who voted for who, its better that way.

Ps. I voted Mayweather but both are greats of their era no doubt.

 

Shane's legacy is tarnished becasue he cheated by using steroids whereas PBF is a clean fighter. A cheater can never be rated higher than clean competitor.

 

No probs, I checked your post count before replying, normally I will refuse to tell who I voted for if your a regular & you dont do an open poll... Im dead against it, I dont even think it should be an option, it achieves nothing other than enabling people to vote for their favourites even if they dont believe it, knowing they dont have to explain themselves.

:good

 

I rate Floyd higher, but I wish he had Shanes sense of adventure.

 

I have to rate Floyd higher, Shane has been busted cheating and in cheating he won world titles, so to me that takes him down a notch, Floyd though I hate his style has done everything the clean way, However just becuase I rate Floyd higher dont get me wrong but I respect Shane more, he takes more risk

 

I like Shane more, and I respect him more, but I think Floyd has been the greater fighter, I rate him higher.

 

Shane

 

If their resumes were switched Shane would be undefeated and Floyd would be like 34-11