Who do you believe Fighter of the year should be

:good

 

From Caguas Puerto Rico! Miguel Angel COTTOOOO!!!!!
**** Pavlik Cotto did better

 

mayweather beating odh and hatton is big on paper
but i like the kelly pavlik koing miranda and then taylor more then anything right now.
cotto beating or tko judah and then beating shane in a ud is good to.

id say

kelly
mayweather
cotto
pac


in that order

 

pavlik

 

Good post.

 

You obviously haven't seen (m)any Hatton fights

 

Any reasoning?

 

Well I'd imagine he'd pretty soundly dominate him! Skill differential aside, the size difference would be an unsurmountable problem for Ricky... but then he's not fighting Joe Calzaghe is he. atsch

 

Pavlik has nothing going against him this year. If Floyd wins he will get it but Hatton shouldn't if he wins. Cotto is just behind the MW champ but only Pavlik is worth.

 

cotto

 

Pavlik:good

 

Spot On.

The only guy who comes close in terms of MULTIPLE big wins is Pavlik - Miranda and Taylor.

 

The only guy who comes close in terms of MULTIPLE big wins is Pavlik - Miranda and Taylor.[/quote]Let's not forget Zertuche when talking about Pavlik. Oddly it was the only fight this year where Kelly was expected to win but had arguably his toughest challenge especially if you take away rd 2 of Pavlik-Taylor. Anyone who has seen the Zertuche fight knows what I'm talkin about. So 3 big fights(2 eliminators and 1 title fight)all won by ko in rd 7 to become the new middleweight champion= Fighter of the Year. Mayweather? He struggled against an old DLH and will soon struggle with a blown up LWW. Cheers:good

 

why shouldn't hatton if he beats mayweather? moving up in weight to beat the p4p #1, lol that would be enough on it's own. but ko'ing castillo who had never gone down before would make it a certainty

 

:good:bbb:bbb