Who do you have higher on your ATG list: James Toney or Floyd Mayweather?

Tyson was there?

Good question.

 

he was very poorly disciplined and wasnt dedicated to the sport.thats the general feeling anyway.also that loss to jones did him no favours either

 

Losing to Jones was a minor hurdle, but losing to Griffin twice damaged his career. Added on to his defeats to Sam Peter at heavyweight, he's lost a fair few big fights that if he had won, he would likely be higher on the ATG list.

 

i voted toney for the hell of it..

 

Losing to Griffen did hurt, but losing to a prime jones shouldn't be held against anyone. I think Toney has had a great career, but wonder how much better it could have been if he was more dedicated. Still, he is one of my favorite fighters to watch, and is always willing to fight the best. Floyd has had some great wins, and no matter what anyone says, he does take some risky fights. I don't think you can easily place either of these two fighters accurately on and all time great list until they have been retired for a bit. Both are so polarizing they can cloud peoples judgment

 

Always thought this guy could have been the best of the last 20 years but he didn't have the drive to do it. Great quote machine however.

 

Im pist off at Mayweather and ive always liked Toney but this isnt even close. Mayweather by far, Toney was too inconsistent thru the years.

 

Add to the fact that he was fighting in divisions that were largely unpopular and the time he was established.

 

Floyd.

 

Mayweather, this isn't even close. James Toney was far too inconsistent, lost too many big fights.

 

Mayweather.

 

pbf by a mile

 

mayweather is a top 40atg, james is nowhere near mayweather IMO...looks like 10 people (so far) voted with their hearts and not their heads (pause)