Who do you lads have ranked higher ATG? Hopkins or Mayweather

I don't see how people can even argue he's an ATG because of this. What has he actually done that's particularly impressive above 135?

Mosley is far superior because he's continued looking for challenges ever since he left 135.

 

You've never seen me box then.

 

I appreciate Hopkins - he's very clever and uses everything within his power to find ways to outsmart his opponent. But I am staggered by Mayweather. He's an absolute fighting genius with far more strings to his bow.

 

Yep, true.

 

Yer beat me 2 it, B-Hop Undisputed 160 CHAMP, demolished TiTo, schools Tarver (Univerally acknowleged Lt/Heavyweight boss & Pavlik Universally Acknowleged Middleweight boss) & at his ripe old age of 40+ something:smoke & who's floyd been in with lately:think

Marquez.....disgracefull match-up
Hatton.......Limited euro world champ
DLH...........past sell by date
Baldimir......Limited brawler
Judah........Erratic underacheiver
Gatti.........past sell by date
Pacquiao....another midgit

No contest, it's B-Hop all the way until Money fights someone his own size & dominates a division + he's avoided all the bad *******s at WW to date:deal

 

How many people above his career weightclass has Bernard ever beat?

 

Don't delude yourself fanboy Hopkins isn't in Floyds league P4P. Hopkins spent most of his career beating guys smaller than him to make a name for himself, was ultimately beaten by Taylor , went up & beat a tailor made Tarver, got outworked and tried cheating versus Calzaghe, again fought smaller guys out of their prime weight classes in Winky/Pavlik before consistently ducking Dawson whilst chasing a 1 dimensional Adamek.

 

You're developing a bit of an obsession with me aren't you? Desperate, attention seeking girls from forums don't float my boat. Maybe you should give Zelenoff a shout.

 

I voted for Hopkins because I'm sick of Floyd and hid cherrypicking ways. Maybe he deserved Marquez because if his ring inactivity but he still shows no sign that he will fight an ellite welterweight when it's the hottest division in the world right now with out a doubt!

I also think Hopkins has beat better the opposition.... Wright, Tarver (masterclass) Pavlik, De la Hoya (not his best weight, but still a world champ at middle) Trinidad and Glen Johnson who he knocked out!

Compare that to Floyds and Hopkins does it for me. No doubt being a five weight world champion is very impressive and was quite frankly incredible at super feather and lightweight in which he beat all challlengers who were very tough.... like Corrales, Hernandez and Castillo.... but since then has cherrypicked his way through the weights not fighting ONE elite welterweight along the way! a washed up Judah who got beat by Baldimor don't count.... neither does Baldimor for that matter!

 

I've gone for Hopkins. Though I think Mayweather definately has the potential to topple him if he beats Mosley, Pac-Cotto winner and Paul Williams. Can't see him fighting those fights tho (apart from Pac if he wins).

 

Hopkins at the moment, clearly. Better resume, as skilled (in his own right) and balls.