Who Do You Rank Higher _ Marciano Or Frazier??

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by Fergy, Oct 28, 2020.

Who do you rate higher?

  1. Rocky Marciano?

    35.9%
  2. Joe Frazier?

    64.1%
  1. janitor

    janitor Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    67,726
    18,680
    Feb 15, 2006
    Marciano for me, but I would not be outraged by the contrary position!
     
  2. mark ant

    mark ant Uysk could beat Haye and Nelson on the same night Full Member

    33,796
    15,005
    May 4, 2017
    Frazier was ranked No.40 in the ring mag in 1996 in a list of the best 50 P4P fighters in the last 50 years.
    Quality of competition: 10
    Why he was ranked 40th: He won the biggest bout in boxing history
    What he could have done to rank higher: Met Foreman in Zaire instead of Kingston.

    Marciano was ranked No.12 in the same list.
    Quality of competition: 7
    He was voted 12th because you can`t argue with perfection.
    What he could have done to improve his ranking: Beating Louis ten years before he did.
     
    BCS8 and Richard M Murrieta like this.
  3. Jackomano

    Jackomano Boxing Junkie Full Member

    7,564
    5,832
    Nov 22, 2014
    Has to be Marciano, since he was consistent with his conditioning and continued to grow as s fighter throughout his career. I like both fighters, but Frazier became complacent after winning the FOTC by not staying in shape and continuing to grow as a fighter.
     
    Richard M Murrieta, RockyJim and BCS8 like this.
  4. HolDat

    HolDat Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,780
    1,946
    Sep 25, 2020
    From a management standpoint, I think there was a reason for Rocky's "shorter" career.
     
    Richard M Murrieta likes this.
  5. RulesMakeItInteresting

    RulesMakeItInteresting Boxing Addict Full Member

    6,809
    8,015
    Mar 23, 2019
    Marciano, but this is a tough call for me. Marciano did indeed beat basically the best of the day, whether they were past it or not that seems to be the truth he retired never having tasted defeat.

    Joe Frazier has more heart than most any heavyweight who ever lived. He defeated a still-badass, undefeated, under-thirty Muhammad Ali. He wiped out the whole division in the late 60s and early part of the 70s.

    Like I said, it's real tough, and I'm completely simpatico with anyone whom chooses Joe first. This was a really hard decision for me.
     
    Last edited: Oct 30, 2020
  6. Fergy

    Fergy Walking Dead Full Member

    17,570
    17,131
    Jan 8, 2017
    Good post.
     
  7. Brockton Rock

    Brockton Rock Member Full Member

    165
    120
    Feb 24, 2020
    Rocky pretty easily, this a joke?

    H2H it's Marciano KO in 8
     
    Richard M Murrieta, BCS8 and RockyJim like this.
  8. ForemanJab

    ForemanJab Boxing Junkie Full Member

    11,910
    6,376
    May 8, 2014
  9. Fergy

    Fergy Walking Dead Full Member

    17,570
    17,131
    Jan 8, 2017
    The votes getting closer!
     
  10. RulesMakeItInteresting

    RulesMakeItInteresting Boxing Addict Full Member

    6,809
    8,015
    Mar 23, 2019
    I'm not so sure on this at all. Though Marciano might edge Joe as an ATG, Joe could definitely hurt him and...I mean, Joe was always warmed up in the middle rounds as opposed to most of his opponents (whom often used those rounds to take a breather).

    Perhaps Rocky could catch Joe with a bomb in the last rounds...I could conceive of that. But he would have to walk through fire with Joe, no doubt in my mind. Joe had too much heart, and though Rocky could be a pretty phenomenal puncher, he wasn't George Foreman.
     
    Fergy likes this.
  11. Fergy

    Fergy Walking Dead Full Member

    17,570
    17,131
    Jan 8, 2017
    I'll second this. It would be a terrific war between Smokin Joe and the Rock, a real clash. But it's Joe I see coming out the Victor. Hed stop Rock in around 7to 8 rounds imo, Marciano being to brave for his own sake.
     
  12. BCS8

    BCS8 Obsessed with Boxing banned Full Member

    43,454
    44,331
    Aug 21, 2012
    Easily ... no. But I do think Rocky should be ahead.
     
  13. Man_Machine

    Man_Machine Boxing Addict Full Member

    6,470
    5,353
    Jun 9, 2010
    Frazier, for mine.

    Not a huge amount in it (I have Frazier at #6 and Marciano at #7).

    On balance, Frazier beat a better class of opposition and his victory over Ali has an almost incalculable quality. It rates so much higher than any of Marciano's wins that, whilst Walcott and Charles were great victories, they can't really make up enough ground to compare with Frazier's ledger. In addition, if I recall correctly, Frazier has a few more successful title defenses, to boot.

    Sure - Marciano has the badge of being undefeated and this is the only aspect of Marciano's record, which weighs in his favor, in my opinion (I think Joe beats Rocky, head-to-head, as well). However, Frazier only registered losses to Ali and Foreman, which is not particularly damaging to his overall account - certainly not enough to diminish the plus-points to the extent that he drops below Marciano. There's too much in Frazier's favor, here.
     
  14. Brockton Rock

    Brockton Rock Member Full Member

    165
    120
    Feb 24, 2020
    I'm sure some here would pick 81 Frazier over any version of Rock
     
    Richard M Murrieta likes this.
  15. Cojimar 1946

    Cojimar 1946 Active Member Full Member

    1,406
    732
    Nov 23, 2014
    Rocky being the best of his era and Frazier not is a pretty heavy factor in his favor rating wise.

    If we are just going to throw out losses than what stops David Tua from rating ahead of Marciano or Tony Tucker
     
    Richard M Murrieta likes this.