Who do you rank higher all-time pound-for-pound: Felix Trinidad or Joe Calzaghe?

That's my point. Tito tested himself against the best. Fighting guys like DLH and Hopkins and Vargas. Yeah Hopkins beat him like a dog but lets see Calzaghe move to Cruiserweight and fight Haye. See how great he does.

Tito dared to be great. Calzaghe dared to be ordinary.

 

Calzaghe never fought fighters of those caliber. He esp never stepped up 3 or 5 weight classes to do so.

 

I give Calzaghe a slight edge even though Tito's fought the better fighters, for the simple reason that Calzaghe is the more versatile fighter and is a tougher matchup. Tito did more with his prime, but Joe's done enough late in his career to eke out a slim victory- I wouldn't have a problem if anyone preferred Tito's early greatness and overall depth of resume over Joe's though.

 

Why are you people giving Calzaghe credit for his skills and talents when talking about who is the greater fighter??? By some of your logic Gamboa should be #1 P4P right now and top 10 all time.