Who do you rank higher ATG? Floyd Mayweather Jr or Thomas Hearns

They'd be comparable if Floyd lost twice to Maidana, once by knockout.

 

Typical flow mo dispreoeting ting one of the greates t fights in boxing ever ! Let's us know when Fraud was ever in a fight with another great in his prime like that genius !

 

No they'd be comparable if Floyd had the ***** to fight GGG. But he doesn't so they're not.

 

Hearns was a peds user.

 

Hearns.

Wins over:

Duran
Leonard (rematch robbery)
Benitez
Hill
Cuevas
Curry
Shuler

Are better than:

Pacquiao
De La Hoya
Cotto
Corrales
Castillo
Hatton
Canelo



His losses don't take away from that gap in achievement, especially when 2 of them were to a level of fighter Floyd simply never faced. It's not a huge gap, but it's there. Hearns's wins shine brighter. He was greater.

 

so wait who did hearns beat again

 

Hearns. He put it on the line, with Mayweather you are stuck with,"what ifs".

 

Hearns' looks better with rose colored glasses. But where is the evidence. What prime ATG did he beat?

 

It's Floyd, and it's not relatively close.

 

It's interesting that he accomplished this plus a guy like Canelo to add but many still don't think it's enough

I will say that Floyd didn't really have the comp Hearns had floating around his weight area

 

Of course it's close, you droning little fool !

 

Damn right it is close. Hearns' wins are better, but then he also has losses. So do we go with the undefeated record or the better wins with losses? To me PBF edges ahead - in terms of resume. H2H, Hearns wins all day long.

 

I've never watched a Floyd fight and then afterwards sat in awe witnessing greatness.

I've done that after a couple Hearns fights.

Never after watching a Floyd fight.

 

:goodGreat to see you around these parts! Ya we're probably gonna retire there. I'll be a regular in Gorman's lol. Kevin Finnegan's da is from Ballyholland down the road a ways.

 

Hearns!