Who do you rank higher pound for pound Cotto or Margarito

Marquez up one, Hopkins down one.

Everything else is fine.

 

Cotto hands down.

 

Cotto no question about it!!

 

You mean between a champion and a cheater?

 

Cotto easy.

 

Both are oustide of the top 10 p4p for me, but of course Cotto

 

I'd have Abraham instead of Caballero and Marquez above B-Hop. Other than that, good list.

I believe Cotto should be above Margarito at the present time.

 

What??????????atsch

 

Cotto behind Donaire?!?!?!

Donaire has beaten Vic. Hasn't done much over the past year or so.

Cotto-Loss to Margarito following wins over Gomez (a gimmee fight no doubt) but that followed wins over Mosley, Judah, Quintana, Corley, Torres.....lots of top contenders. Cotto has one loss from someone who may or may not have beaten him with the help of illegal wraps.

Donaire has beaten one guy who has gone on and shown improvement, and in turn beaten some very, very good fighters. Donaire has done nothing, this guy is seriously overrated.

P4P skills? No doubt. P4P resume or indeed, recent form? No, not at all.

 

i dont like hatton being 10 and w. klitschko sucks

calzaghe is retired so your list is pretty good just dont like those two being in that position :thumbsup

 

Pavlik should be in that list

 

I'd have Cotto above Margarito, and a bit higher on the list overall.

 

Some people were ready to put Cotto P4P#1 if he beat Margarito, in light of recent events I think he should still be top 10. His win over Mosley looks better than ever, too.

 

Arthur Abraham ahead of Caballero. Do you need me to say it again before you understand it? atsch