Who do you rate higher as an ATG: Tyson, Lewis or Holyfield?

Lewis...easily.

 

Nah Holy fought everuyone and posted up some solid wins when has Oscar had as many solid wins as Holy ?? Sorry nice try but no comparison ..:good

 

agreed and cosigned.

 

i would tend to agree with you...though i think that the holyfield edging out the great dwight muhammad qawi over 15 brutal, busy rounds in only his 12th pro fight is a pretty remarkable achievement and sort of set the tone for the rest of holy's remarkable career.

 

..... Where did you get that....?

Oh **** it ok.

 

Indeed and he has a win over Bowe as well ..Too bad we never got Bowe Lewis ..I would have loved to see those 2 big men go at it ..

 

Holyfield, Lewis, then Tyson. Holyfield fought better guys when they were at their prime. (Moorer, Bowe(3), Douglas, Tyson after he showed dominance). Not to mention his cruiserweight accomplishments. Should still have a belt since the Valuev robbery. Lewis fought most of his legends past their prime(Tyson, Holyfield). Holyfield has more accomplishments by a clear margin and even their 2nd fight was a close one which says even more for Holyfield. Tyson did clean out the division in his prime at least.

 

I'll take that as a compliment. :twisted:

 

arty:ldevil

 

This is tough. Holyfield had the greater fights but Lewis did dominate. In the heavyweights it is tough to rate them since Lewis outweighed everyone by so much. I think Evander is the better fighter p4p, but Lewis was just a heavy guy at heavy and had a good right hand, so if he hit guys with that punch they were knocked out usually.