Who do you think will end up as the greatest UFC fighter ever..GSP-Silva-Penn?

BJ imo being able to pick up a title in that secound weight agianst a guy on Hughes level means alot to me.

 

Silva and Machida made it clear they would never fight. Thank godness for that because im 100 percent sure that fight would be worse then the Hopkins/Jones fight from Saturday.

 

It's hard to say. They are all phenomonal fighters who look unbeatable at their weight. Their legacies will probably be determined by their success in multiple weights. BJ can go up and beat loads of contenders at 170. Silva can do that at 205. However people aren't sure if GSP can handle the step up.

 

BJ Penn gets big credits for finding the big challenges moving up to fight guys like Machida, huges and Gsp at there own weights and doing well against all of them. Looks to finish fights

Silva is just starting too fight at LHW, has done very well so far. his MW title run has been amazing and he has got the record for most concecitive wins. Looks to finish fights

GSP has been dominating really good welterweights, has made them look poor. But he wont move up or try hard to finish the fight.

To me its Silva>Penn>GSP right now.

 

I don't think GSP can be considered the greatest if he never wins the middleweight belt. If Shogun beats Machida, then Silva beats Shogun, I'd back Silva as the best of the three. But right now, it's got to be Penn IMO.

Though all of them are behind Fedor.

 

P4P fight - Penn vs Silva? Who would you pick?!

 

Silva

 

Penn.

Id expect Penn to get the TD as Silvas TDD is not so great.

Then it would be a pass guard mount pound RNC.

Florian is as good a BB as Silva p4p and BJ treated him like a kid on the ground.

 

GSP is still young.. BJ pissed away many good years, likely some prime, or close to prime years. If he trained and had the dedication to match his talent, we might talk about him like a small version of Fedor.

 

fedor once he breaks lesners jaw

 

Exactly as I see it...