Who do you think won Mayweather/Castillo I?

but again if you have it 7-5 because of the point deduction you scored it a draw

 

I've only watched it one time and i think Castillo won and i have to admit that i am a Floyd nuthugger That was his toughest fight.

 

Yep was a draw w/o the point deduction. But I say 7-5 was my unoffical scoring with the point deduction.

 

I had Castillo winning a close but clear decision, he gave out many of the early rounds but did take the lead down the stretch and did enough to take the win.

 

Castillo 7-5 if we ignore all the point deduction jokery

 

i had castillo winning that fight by 3 rounds and i was absoloutly gobsmacked with how the judges scored that fight.
pbf is a great fighter but he lost that fight and no one could ever convince me otherwise.

 

I haven't seen the fight in a long time, but I remember I had Castillo winning the fight. 8-4 maybe? A lot of the rounds were close though. Mayweather won the rematch convincingly, albeit closely.

 

I was not a huge boxing fan back then, so I didnt know any of the guys who fought. I remember I thought that the mexican guy really whooped on the black guy, then later on when I became a big fan and scored it rbr I had it much closer but still had Castillo winning 115-113.

 

I had Castillo winning by 1 or 2 points, but there were some close rounds and Floyd could have won the fight.

 

PBF won in a really close fight that could have gone either way. JLC gave up too many early rounds. Hard fight to score because a lot of the shots Castillo threw were blocked. With that being said PBF gave JLC an immediate rematch and won going away.

 

:good

 

No doubt in my mind Castillo was robbed. I say robbed because the WORST he could have gotten was a draw and they ****ed him out of even that.

 

I dont think this was a robbery at all there where so many rounds in the fight that could've went either way for instance I had it 10-8 Mayweather in the round Castillo got a pioint deducted and many had it 9-9 same thing with round 10 I had it 9-9 and some had it 10-8 Castillo....Anyway I had the fight 5-4-3 Mayweather, but like I said those 3 rds could have went to Castillo to alot of peeps so that would give Castillo the nod. Being the CHAMP I would have gave the fight to Castillo, but couldn't see it being a "robbery" cause it was just to close. IMHO

 

Castillo took that. If PBF won the first one then theirematch would of been the same. Floyd fought totally different in the sequel, he did the running man impression 12 rds